Re: Re: Re: macs and reducing the cost of higher education
Originally posted by jefhatfield
So, after playing devils advocate, how do you think we can reduce costs...let's say that governor davis hired you today and that was your job and he said, "give me results"
ok, now i was an mba and law student...the degree after the JD is a llm (a master's degree) and the degree after that is the JSD (the doctorate degree of law)...a law degree has been for three hundred years a second bachelor's degree and for only for the last 30 has it been considered a graduate degree
educational institutions, city, county, and federal government all put a person with a JD in the pay scale as one with two bachelor's degrees, and not at the level of someone who has a master's or PhD
so why charge doctorate level tuition at law schools...give the law students a break
and as far as the mba, let a non-business student get conditionally accepted into an mba program and let that student take those undergrad level courses at undergrad level tuition...and give those students a break and why charge them full graduate level tuition learning the basics of econ, accounting, finance, marketing, and management
so mr mcrain, you are now appointed by jefhatfield and governor davis to help our great state of california
give me your 2 cents
also the reason a JD is not called "Dr." is because that is the title for someone who has a JSD (who has already earned the llm and basic JD)
I just applied for a federal position, and attorneys go in between GS-11 and GS-14 now.
The LLM is a masters in law, and there is a doctorate in law, so yes, there are advanced degrees beyond the Juris Doctorate, however, that does not mean the JD isn't a doctorate level education. To say so would basically imply that to get a doctorate in the legal profession you have to have more than twice the amount of education anyone else needs to get a doctorate. (That's sort of silly) To get a masters after undergrad, you go to school for a year or so, to get a doctorate, you go to school for 3 years or so, to be an MD, you go to school for 4 years. Law school is 3 years. The only difference is that there isn't anything for an MD or PhD to do after getting their doctorate, while a JD has even more levels of education they can do. (usually, llm's are masters not in law [in general], but in rather a masters in a specific area of the law)
Ok, that was the easy part of the response. You've asked some tough questions.
Honest answer is I have no idea what would work best for California.
That being said, there are a few things I would do. In the pre-college levels, I would work very hard at getting higher quality teachers and somehow paying them what they are worth. Second, in the pre-college years, I would get rid of the idea of throwing all kids in the same classrooms regardless of intelligence or motivation. (If you have to take 30 ritilin a day and disrupt the class, I'm sorry, but you shouldn't be in with the kids who can do calculus in 4th grade)
As for college, the State should, if it has not done so already, provide tax incentives for paying for college educations. The state should also provide scholorships for kids who go into specialties so long as they teach for a few years (5 years?) (sort of like the military).
Post-grad education shouldn't have its costs reduced. If you make it cheap to become a Dr. or easier to become one, you flood the market with people. (see for e.g. your comment about too many lawyers and doctors in cali).
To make post grad available to qualified people, the state could offer scholorships for teaching service (an additional 3-5 years?) or low interest rate specialized loans (at the cost of 1-2 years of teaching service).
As you can see, the biggest educational problem in my mind isn't that people can't afford to get an education (they can get loans), but rather that we are failing the kids who will enter college later. Those kids need the best possible education so that when they get to college, they are straining at the bit to do more, learn more, and do more than the people teaching them. Right now, I don't see that happening.