I'm torn between the two. The Magpul seems like a steal at $10 and people tend to recommend it heavily in this forum. However the NGP gets a lot of nods as well and I do like the Incipio brand ... I have one of their two-piece hybrids and love (though don't use it often as 2-pieces are naturally a bit bulker.) I wanted to put these two up against each other because they extremely similar in design and materials. Let me know what your experiences have been. Any idea which adds less bulk?