We need to all give up on Magsafe making a return. It definitely isnt going to be brought back to our machines in the future.
Agree/Disagree?
Agree/Disagree?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Magsafe is gone for good. Lets all move on
- Thread starter simplysly
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Just buy a third party magnetic cable. There's loads of them.
Are there any you can recommend that support fast charging (up to 100W) and have minimal protrusion from the adapter plugged into the Macbook?
I bought this one for my 13" MBP (I can recommend this one, though it's "only" 87w): https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07H7BNJBS/
A quick search for Magsafe + 100w revealed several options, this was the first one: https://www.amazon.com/Magnetic-Charging-Transfer-Chromebook-Nintendo/dp/B07WYY6G4S/
A quick search for Magsafe + 100w revealed several options, this was the first one: https://www.amazon.com/Magnetic-Charging-Transfer-Chromebook-Nintendo/dp/B07WYY6G4S/
We have, it seems you haven't ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
It was evident in 2016 when apple dropped it.
ELECJET MagJet S, 20 Pin Magnetic USB-C Adapter, 100W Fast Charge, 10 Gb/s Data Transfer, 4K Video 60Hz High Resolution Compatible with MacBook Pro and Other USB-C Devices(Silver+Gray)
ELECJET MagJet S, 20 Pin Magnetic USB-C Adapter, 100W Fast Charge, 10 Gb/s Data Transfer, 4K Video 60Hz High Resolution Compatible with MacBook Pro and Other USB-C Devices(Silver+Gray)
www.amazon.co.uk
This one is an adapter, so very flexible. 100W. Includes data transfer.
Why?
Besides, there are days, when I would like to see a return to internal CD/DVD drives.
Nevertheless, while it is one thing to start a thread stating that "Magsafe" (an excellent idea, by the way and very useful one) is "gone" (even "gone for good"), it is quite another to demand, or insist, that people "move on". Why should they?
Anyway, early because I am a bit of a curmudgeon, and partly because I really do Like MagSafe, I am registering my disagreement.
I moved on in 2016 when I got the new MBP. It turns out having a common charge port among multiple devices is actually pretty great. I can charge my iPad Pro and X1 Carbon with the same cable, and as devices adopt USB-C charging I can use those cables in a pinch as well. Looking forward to iPhones getting on the USB-C bandwagon.
There's 3rd-party cables or adapters or whatever that add a break point. Whether Apple should have done that themselves is debatable. The dedicated MagSafe port was a great idea but its time has passed.
There's 3rd-party cables or adapters or whatever that add a break point. Whether Apple should have done that themselves is debatable. The dedicated MagSafe port was a great idea but its time has passed.
You can disagree with apple removal but there's a point where people have to admit that Apple is never to return to the "good ol days"
Hm, USB C power delivery is capped at 100W so assuming Apple ever made a machine which necessarily exceeded this? Of course that's just baseless speculation, but worth pointing out there's a not too farfetched scenario in which Apple would have to abandon USB C charging.
No, I beg to differ.
While I have no issue with threads that argue that the day of the MagSafe (or some other Apple component) is gone, - and one can have a discussion or disagreement about that, preferably civil, - I find it presumptuous if threads, or posts, attempt to adopt a stance of insisting on that others "move on", or presuming to tell others what to do.
To me, this seems extraordinarily arrogant.
Not arrogant, just facing facts. Apple chose a technology and in doing so doomed another to the scrap heap. You can continue to hold onto the ideal that apple will reverse course and re-add the mag-safe but that's highly unlikely. I'm not sure why you consider this extraordinarily arrogant when the removal of mag-safe was done 3 1/2 years ago.
I think it extraordinarily arrogant to all people "to move on"; the MagSafe just happens to be the topic of discussion and/or disagreement today.
Discuss, debate the removal of the MagSafe, by all means, but the use of this condescending - and yes, to a European, perhaps it is a cultural difference - but I find the use of the term "move on", arrogating to oneself the right to determine how someone else should think about something - extraordinarily arrogant.
Is it arrogant to state that its time to face facts? since apple dropped the technology in 2016, and we're about to flip the calendar to 2020? You want to hold on hope that Apple will return to the days of the mag-safe, be my guest. I as others were only stating that it is time to move on. Yes a discussion of USB-C vs. mag-safe is valid, but that doesn't diminish the fact that apple not going to re-add a legacy component that is already being handled by the USB-C port.
Everyone was being polite and discussing this with maturity - It was you who started with the condescending comments accusing others of being extraordinarily arrogant.
Either way, I can see no further good coming as the tone of the posts seem to be turning rather negative. I personally don't like being called extraordinarily arrogant - I'm out.
It’s like the fundamental human right to privacy in the USA, and other countries. It’s gone. Best move on. /s
Anyone try this one? I'm moving from mid-2015 rMBP to late 2019 16" rMBP and refusing to give up Mag safe
elecjet.com
MagThunder X: Magnetic Thunderbolt 3 adapter, 24 Pins Design Compatible with MacBook Pro/Air and any USB C Laptops
Features ELECJET MagThunder X is the first and slimmest magnetic USB C adapter that fully supports Thunderbolt 3 data transfer. Also, it is fully reversible that get back MagSafe feature to new MacBook (Pro/Air)/ iPad Pro and other USB C laptops or devices.