Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Having Apps in the App Store since the beginning I will never believe the earlier delays were for deeper checks. The delay was because they wanted the developers to think there were deeper checks, but the times my apps were delayed were for stupid reasons and almost always because the reviewer had no idea what they were doing.

I figured that Apple's initial policy of turnaround time was social engineering attempt to incentivize developers to test their apps better, knowing that they couldn't quickly deploy a bug fix.

-R
 
  • Like
Reactions: nt5672
It's OK - kids don't use crypto wallets, they are safe! And that is what matters.

P.S. You'd think that random app requesting full access to photos library would trigger red flags, but hey, Apple vetting process is too advanced...
 
I think we all know the walled garden is there to increase their profits rather protect their customers.
You forgot being a Moral Police as well.

Toddler: Mommy, Daddy, where do babies comes from?
Mom and Dad: Let’s ask Siri, Hey Siri where do babies comes from?
Siri: Let me check the internet for you.
Siri: My programming does not permit this information.
Toddler: Do babies come from the internet if permitted?
Mom and Dad: Babies are programmed 🫠
 
  • Like
Reactions: Grigori Wulfric
Disappointing to see this. App store review process has to improve. Most of my apps have only the 'Limited Access' permission to access Photos. Have never given full access to any app unless it is absolutely necessary.
 
My app called Altershot uses full Photos access to show screenshots which you can edit. It won’t work as well with system Photos picker, it would require more taps from my customers.
oh, another issue here too - you dont need access to full library, you need access to screenshots.
 
See. This is what happens when you allow 3rd party app stores.

What's that? This was found on Apple's App Store? 😲
Even though the tone is sarcastic, many of us were posting the same thing. Security is a cat and mouse game and 3rd party app stores will be ripe for this type of thing.

Apple will have to raise the bar on the review process.
 
...uh, the simple solution is to *think* before answering 'yes' to some unknown, 3rd-party apps' request to get access to your photo library (or contacts or calendar or....) A bit of common sense goes a long way.
 
  • Love
Reactions: turbineseaplane
I dunno, there are cases where apps have legit good reasons for accessing photos.

But those need to be LEGIT GOOD REASONS (necessary and even core to app functionality), and any app using photo access APIs should be under special scrutiny at review.
Which then can expand to almost every API. You know what will happen next: app will ask for 100+ permissions just to start, and 50+ more later, as all of those API are scrutinised and need explicit user permission.
 
how does Apple check the apps? do they really have a human reading all the code for each app on each update before they publish it?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Grigori Wulfric
So, why don't mention all that they do catch? Love how people gloss over all the things they do catch. Security is always an uphill battle. But, Imagine if nobody was reviewing your apps at all.
I’m more than happy to thank Apple for their efforts to identify and delete scam apps. That’s why I continue to buy iPhones and use the AppStore. But let’s be realistic, this is a marketing tool as much as anything. It’s intended to make us feel safe and secure in their walled garden. The truth is nobody knows how many scam apps get through their vetting process. I trust Apple more than I trust Google which is why I’m happy to stay within their walled garden.
 
Even though the tone is sarcastic, many of us were posting the same thing. Security is a cat and mouse game and 3rd party app stores will be ripe for this type of thing.

Apple will have to raise the bar on the review process.
Someone seems to have a lot of angry responses today... all over this thread.
Dont recall a comment on why anywhere...
 
  • Like
Reactions: I7guy
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.