MBA 11" 2015 tests slower than 2013

Discussion in 'MacBook Air' started by solmaker, Nov 6, 2016.

  1. solmaker macrumors member

    Joined:
    Nov 23, 2007
    #1
    When Apple killed the MBP 17", I immediately ordered the the last best late 2011 maxed-out refurb model, which turned out to be one of my best purchases ever... it's still going strong and I happily use it daily.

    So when Apple just killed the MBA 11", I was feeling disenchanted by announced offerings so (inspired by my successfull MBP 17" experience), I ordered the last best 2015 maxed-out refurb model before it disappeared from the refurb store, even though its specs were only a marginal improvement over my road-warrier 2013 model.

    I was very surprised when I got my hands on the 2015 baby that it was noticeably SLOWER in my real-world testing using an identical Macintosh HD partition. Three data points:

    1) 2013 model boot time to the login screen was noticeably faster than the 2015 model.

    2) However when passwords were entered at the same time, the 2015 model logged in faster than 2013.

    3) Computation-heavy compilation of a big program composed of hundreds of files in a VMware Fusion Windows session was noticeably faster using the 2013 model than the 2015 one.

    My read on this is that though the 2015 model has a faster 2.2 GHz CPU than the 2013 1.7 GHz CPU, the 2015 must have a much slower SSD than the 2013 model (even though both have similar APPLE SSD SM512 chipset identifiers). That would account for the slower boot time loading OS files from SSD into memory before reaching the login screen, as well as the faster login process once already in memory given the faster CPU in the 2015 model. I assume the slower SSD reading scattered source files also led to slower compilation despite the faster CPU.

    Since my 2013 MBA seemed the same or better than the 2015 model in my own use case tests, I returned it to Apple the next day. So that's my story to anyone else tempted to go for the last remaining MBA 11" refurbs.
     
  2. solmaker thread starter macrumors member

    Joined:
    Nov 23, 2007
    #2
    I just realized that the maxed-out 2013 MBA ramps up to 3.3 GHz while the 2015 ramps up to only 3.2 GHz, so the older model actually wins on Turbo Burst speed (aside from any architecture improvements between 2013 and 2015).
     
  3. eddjedi macrumors 6502

    Joined:
    Sep 7, 2011
    #3
    If you have cloned your old hard drive on to the new MBA, make sure you have set the startup disk. This catches me out every time and I wonder why it's taking a minute to boot.

    And yes, this is exactly why I have just bought a 2013 i7 instead of the 2015 model. Sadly Apple are sacrificing performance for style these days.
     
  4. Boyd01 macrumors 68040

    Boyd01

    Joined:
    Feb 21, 2012
    Location:
    New Jersey Pine Barrens
    #4
    Seems like that theory could have been easily tested with the Blackmagic app. Anyway, thanks for making me even happier with my 2013 maxxed out 11" MBA. :)
     

Share This Page