Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MBA or MBP

P

parajba

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Apr 19, 2008
513
269
As per title. I was set on a MBA M3 13” 16/512, but then I read that it throttles with games. I don’t game but you it for Zwift, a cycling training app.
I then looked at the MBP 14” 18/512, which would be around £500 more expensive (£1400 vs £1900, maybe £1700 refurbished from Apple).

I don’t travel, so it stays at home but I do value a light and pretty package.

Apart from Zwift, all light use (web, Office).

Any thoughts?

I also value a good keyboard. I would like the larger screen of the Pro. I need it to be quiet when in use, I cannot stand noisy fans.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Cape Dave
Thanks both, yes I am leaning towards the MBA 13 or 15. I wish there was a forum user who actively uses Zwift on the MBA to let me know how it is.
 
parajba said:
As per title. I was set on a MBA M3 13” 16/512, but then I read that it throttles with games. I don’t game but you it for Zwift, a cycling training app.
I then looked at the MBP 14” 18/512, which would be around £500 more expensive (£1400 vs £1900, maybe £1700 refurbished from Apple).

I don’t travel, so it stays at home but I do value a light and pretty package.

Apart from Zwift, all light use (web, Office).

Any thoughts?

I also value a good keyboard. I would like the larger screen of the Pro. I need it to be quiet when in use, I cannot stand noisy fans.
Click to expand...
Mba m2 would be great choice. you can find a model with more ram if you wish
 
I went to the local Apple Store. I played with the 14, then with 13 Air. Jeez, night and day difference. Same processor, but the screen is massively different. I’ve never noticed that. I liked the Air, but now that I tried the 14, well, I don’t like the Air screen anymore. It’s not only about the frequency of scrolling, there was something else. Maybe the size played a role too, but the panel seemed materially better. I browsed the same websites, did exactly the same things. When I went back to the Air, it seemed like an old laptop, which is strange as it’s a very pretty and fast one.

One advantage of the air: the form factor is nicer. I liked both keyboards, but the 14’ felt slightly better with longer travel?

The 14’ is bulkier, perhaps too much for my liking. I don’t travel, it’s my main house computer, but it’s always nice to have light devices to move around the house.

The price delta is material too. We are talking about £500 increase between the two in similar 16/512 config.

In conclusion, I am so undecided!
 
I'm not a serious gamer and am not familiar with Zwift but play Sims 3 and 4 on highest settings for hours on my 13" M2 Air. It gets warm but not hot and I have never experienced a problem. Much easier to move around than my previous 14" Pro.
 
Thanks, interesting that the weight difference is only 100g, I assumed it was more. 1.61kg of the 14 vs 1.51kg of the Air. I think the added thickness makes it look heavier that it actually is.

I found a MBP M3 Pro 18/512 for £1779 refurb official Apple, so the difference is £400.
 
parajba said:
Thanks both, yes I am leaning towards the MBA 13 or 15. I wish there was a forum user who actively uses Zwift on the MBA to let me know how it is.
Click to expand...
You could always get the Air, install the app and put it through its paces. If it can't handle it, return it and use the credit toward the Pro -- if it can, you're good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PlayUltimate
does the A&P® sell macbooks?
they would have that MacBook A&P....air and pro!
and
Tim Cook would stand and make sure
shoppers would have under 8 items or less at the express lanes.

oops, A&P has merged with Stop 'N Shop
i forgot their new name.
 
Still haven’t decided.
Amazon has MBAs M2 albeit 8/256GB on sale for £899. And the M2 8/512 for £999, even more tempting.
 
Last edited:
parajba said:
Thanks, interesting that the weight difference is only 100g, I assumed it was more. 1.61kg of the 14 vs 1.51kg of the Air. I think the added thickness makes it look heavier that it actually is.

I found a MBP M3 Pro 18/512 for £1779 refurb official Apple, so the difference is £400.
Click to expand...
Try matching the RAM specs between them. I chose the 14" MBP M3 Pro refurb since the price was nominally the same as a new 15" Air with 16/512. (US pricing)
 
I bought the MBA M3 13" 16/512 in silver. Very nice.
Typing is so much better than the laptop it replaces, a 2017 MBP with that horrible keyboard.
Fast, light, not too expensive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zimzalabims and bellflyer14
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back