Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mmoran27

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Oct 23, 2006
298
0
I am using a 15 mbp late 2008 2.53. Running on the 9600.

Fans idle at 2000 rpm. Temps are a little high for my taste and really crank up playing a simple youtube video.

Is this normal? My 3.06 GHZ IMAC never gets past 40
 

Attachments

  • Untitled.png
    Untitled.png
    166.6 KB · Views: 69
I am using a 15 mbp late 2008 2.53. Running on the 9600.

Fans idle at 2000 rpm. Temps are a little high for my taste and really crank up playing a simple youtube video.

Is this normal? My 3.06 GHZ IMAC never gets past 40

looks pretty good. but there are a lot of discrepancies among the users here about what temp is "normal"
 
Seems about right, I have temperatures anywhere from 55-50 degrees (celsius) doing the exact same thing, you should be good. Also, you can't really compare the iMac to a MacBook Pro since the way it's put together and I believe the iMac has a bigger fan which helps.
 
Those temps are fine. If you are at all concerned there is a freeware program called "Fan Control" that lets you set the fan's base speed, and the upper and lower temperature thresholds. It works very well.
 
Is it normal for yutube to tax the system?

Are you telling me that a 2500 laptop can't handle YouTube without getting all hot with fans revving to 6000 rmps?

I don't have this problem with my imac or even windows boxes I have.
 
I have the same machine and the same issue. iStat numbers are pretty much the same.

I've noticed though that it only happens when I'm running the 9600 in "higher performance" mode, and usually only when my notebook is in clamshell mode.

I've been surprised by how drastic the heat increases for all components when using the 9600. Twenty degrees plus on the CPU.

Sorry, no help. Just comments.
 
Are you telling me that a 2500 laptop can't handle YouTube without getting all hot with fans revving to 6000 rmps?

I don't have this problem with my imac or even windows boxes I have.

No, it means you are needlessly worrying about your temperatures... possibly causing you to rev your fans to 6000rpm manually.

Nothing is free. If you wish to run a high performance computer in an extremely thin form factor then you are going to have higher temperatures (relative to larger enclosures), fans spinning fast, or both.

Fortunately all of those temps are very well within a safe range.
 
the notebook is a lot hotter no matter what you are doing when using the 9600...

If you are browsing the web, no point having it in high performance.

Unless you are using come GPU accelerated software, or games, there is really no point using the hot performance mode. I've done benchmarks in GeekBench, it tests everything BUT graphics, and I had the same score in both modes.

This might be different for snow leopard where the OS is GPU accelerated, but as it stands now, there is no point using high performance mode because almost everything is done by the CPU.
 
If it isn't on a flat hard surface, expect the fans to go wild. Remember, flash is very processor intensive, hence its absence on the iPhone.
 
Are you telling me that a 2500 laptop can't handle YouTube without getting all hot with fans revving to 6000 rmps?

I don't have this problem with my imac or even windows boxes I have.
The youtube thing is a flash problem. Flash is implemented very poorly on Macs.
 
Are you telling me that a 2500 laptop can't handle YouTube without getting all hot with fans revving to 6000 rmps?

I don't have this problem with my imac or even windows boxes I have.

You're comparing a desktop to a laptop. Not a very good comparasion especially since desktops have a WAY larger heatsink and more air flow.
 
I have the same machine and the same issue. iStat numbers are pretty much the same.

I've noticed though that it only happens when I'm running the 9600 in "higher performance" mode, and usually only when my notebook is in clamshell mode.

I've been surprised by how drastic the heat increases for all components when using the 9600. Twenty degrees plus on the CPU.

Sorry, no help. Just comments.

The main reason why it gets so hot is because you have it in clamshell mode. The air also goes through the spaces between the keys, so you just blocked a fairly major air circulation. Happens to me even with the 9400M in clamshell mode.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.