Couldn't find one thread detailing this; as a mechanical keyboard fan, I figured I'd try to create one place where we could talk about mechanical keyboards, ideally with a Mac focus.
I've used a few switch types at this time... originally bought a mechanical keyboard with a Windows layout because I was doing a lot of typing on a Windows machine that I was remoting into, and had heard good things about them. Went with a G.SKILL Ripjaws KM780R with Cherry MX Brown switches (because I liked the idea of the colors to add a bit of cheer to my work). It didn't feel overly special at first, but when I tried to use my standard Mac keyboard with the scissor keys it felt awful... as did practically every other keyboard. And from then on, it was mechanical keyboards or nothing! I bought a Das Keyboard 4 Professional for Mac to replace my Apple keyboard, again sticking with Cherry MX Brown switches, and was enjoying myself tremendously after that.
More recently, I've been away from home for a time and decided that I was getting tired of my MacBook's keyboard. I bought a Das Professional S in Windows layout with Cherry MX Blue switches and absolutely loved it; when I returned home briefly, I found that my Cherry MX Browns seemed very quiet (they had seemed very loud when I tried them at first, compared with my Mac keyboard) and felt more "mushy." It has me contemplating swapping out my Mac keyboard with a Cherry MX Blue version, or switching to another switch type that is more "clicky."
Most recently I decided that I wanted a keyboard with backlighting - ideally RGB, and not just a single color - and I went with a Das 5Q (have not yet bought the Mac keycaps; still assessing it). It uses Das' custom-made "Gamma Zulu" keycaps, which are supposedly like Cherry MX Reds (which are on the opposite end of the spectrum of the Cherry MX Blues). My impression is that the lighting - after the firmware update - is decent (prior to that it hurt to look at and I had a hard time differentiating the colors from each other, although I can't really explain why), although I'm disappointed that there are no animated lighting effects available... supposedly they're coming. The keyboard is relatively quiet, probably even more quiet than my MX Brown keyboard, and when I initially pressed a few keys I liked the solid feel of it. I've only logged a few hours on it so far, yet I find it a bit fatiguing to type on... ironic, since the actuation force required is less than the Cherry MX Blues. I'll keep at it for a bit, but I'm thinking I might need to continue my search...
Aside from Das, other popular keyboard companies that offer Mac-layout or specifically Mac-compatible keyboards include WASD, Ducky, and Matias. Most of them also offer backlighting, but at this point in time, not RGB (or RGB with mechanical switches).
So, what about the rest of you? Any preferred Mac-specific mechanical keyboards? Any questions about mechanical keyboards?
I've used a few switch types at this time... originally bought a mechanical keyboard with a Windows layout because I was doing a lot of typing on a Windows machine that I was remoting into, and had heard good things about them. Went with a G.SKILL Ripjaws KM780R with Cherry MX Brown switches (because I liked the idea of the colors to add a bit of cheer to my work). It didn't feel overly special at first, but when I tried to use my standard Mac keyboard with the scissor keys it felt awful... as did practically every other keyboard. And from then on, it was mechanical keyboards or nothing! I bought a Das Keyboard 4 Professional for Mac to replace my Apple keyboard, again sticking with Cherry MX Brown switches, and was enjoying myself tremendously after that.
More recently, I've been away from home for a time and decided that I was getting tired of my MacBook's keyboard. I bought a Das Professional S in Windows layout with Cherry MX Blue switches and absolutely loved it; when I returned home briefly, I found that my Cherry MX Browns seemed very quiet (they had seemed very loud when I tried them at first, compared with my Mac keyboard) and felt more "mushy." It has me contemplating swapping out my Mac keyboard with a Cherry MX Blue version, or switching to another switch type that is more "clicky."
Most recently I decided that I wanted a keyboard with backlighting - ideally RGB, and not just a single color - and I went with a Das 5Q (have not yet bought the Mac keycaps; still assessing it). It uses Das' custom-made "Gamma Zulu" keycaps, which are supposedly like Cherry MX Reds (which are on the opposite end of the spectrum of the Cherry MX Blues). My impression is that the lighting - after the firmware update - is decent (prior to that it hurt to look at and I had a hard time differentiating the colors from each other, although I can't really explain why), although I'm disappointed that there are no animated lighting effects available... supposedly they're coming. The keyboard is relatively quiet, probably even more quiet than my MX Brown keyboard, and when I initially pressed a few keys I liked the solid feel of it. I've only logged a few hours on it so far, yet I find it a bit fatiguing to type on... ironic, since the actuation force required is less than the Cherry MX Blues. I'll keep at it for a bit, but I'm thinking I might need to continue my search...
Aside from Das, other popular keyboard companies that offer Mac-layout or specifically Mac-compatible keyboards include WASD, Ducky, and Matias. Most of them also offer backlighting, but at this point in time, not RGB (or RGB with mechanical switches).
So, what about the rest of you? Any preferred Mac-specific mechanical keyboards? Any questions about mechanical keyboards?