Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Love microcenter great store. But have to trek up the GSP to Paterson. Deal is good enough I’ll do it. Tax is 3%.
[doublepost=1567340508][/doublepost]
They haven't been competitive in years, and anyone who pays any attention to what the competition has to offer will agree. Reviews of them tend to all say they are nothing special outside of how easily they connect to iPhones and generally recommend alternatives. They don't do anything better than competitors, and those cheap "chinese knockoffs" mop the floor with them in terms of features, audio quality, battery life and price.
One persons “mop the floor” is another persons “didn’t even leave the starting gate”. Family member bought a set of knockoffs and he received exactly what he paid for in terms of features and functions.

With AirPods no silicon tip required and for that they are worth it.

If all you are looking for is b/t you’re right.
 
Love microcenter great store. But have to trek up the GSP to Paterson. Deal is good enough I’ll do it. Tax is 3%.
[doublepost=1567340508][/doublepost]
One persons “mop the floor” is another persons “didn’t even leave the starting gate”. Family member bought a set of knockoffs and he received exactly what he paid for in terms of features and functions.

With AirPods no silicon tip required and for that they are worth it.

If all you are looking for is b/t you’re right.

I think there's some confusion. here... I'm not talking about direct knockoffs that are essentially counterfeit Airpods. I'm referring to the many, many other brands out there that produce quality wireless earbuds. but that's beside the point. Your family member bought one set of non Airpods, and without knowing what he got there's no way to know if he got crap or not.
 
I think there's some confusion. here... I'm not talking about direct knockoffs that are essentially counterfeit Airpods. I'm referring to the many, many other brands out there that produce quality wireless earbuds. but that's beside the point. Your family member bought one set of non Airpods, and without knowing what he got there's no way to know if he got crap or not.
My point is for the $160 and the convenience of using one or two with no-hassle pairing and firmware updates plus whatever features/functions are part of airpods, they are worth it to me. I'm not debating others may have better noise cancelling (as airpods have none), better sound. But none to my knowledge has better convenience (to me) and don't need a silicon tip...including the more expensive beats.
 
I went by today and saw there were plenty in stock for both APs at Micro Center by me. It is really hard to resist not buying one at this discounted rate.
 
My point is for the $160 and the convenience of using one or two with no-hassle pairing and firmware updates plus whatever features/functions are part of airpods, they are worth it to me. I'm not debating others may have better noise cancelling (as airpods have none), better sound. But none to my knowledge has better convenience (to me) and don't need a silicon tip...including the more expensive beats.

I hear you, and it's important to understand that the features you attribute to the AIrpod are common on competitors going for as little as $50. The only thing you've mentioned that the Airpods do that someone else doesn't is not requiring a silicone tip.
 
I think there's some confusion. here... I'm not talking about direct knockoffs that are essentially counterfeit Airpods. I'm referring to the many, many other brands out there that produce quality wireless earbuds. but that's beside the point. Your family member bought one set of non Airpods, and without knowing what he got there's no way to know if he got crap or not.
Do you feel the Anker's Soundcore true wireless earbuds are one of these "quality" ones you speak of? I previously bought a pair of Anker Soudcore True Wireless headphones as a comparison point to Apple's AirPods. They seemingly address 3 major criticisms against AirPods: 1) They were half the price 2)They were black and 3)They were in-ear sealed

But, the two very quickly differentiate and not in the Soundcore's favor. And it starts with switching them between connected devices. You may poo-poo AirPods ease of moving between Apple devices, but please enlighten me: Tell me about or show me any other Bluetooth "buds", "headphones", or headsets that can effortlessly be swapped between your phone, tablet, laptop, desktop, TV, or Watch devices. The Soundcore allowed you to pair them by bluetooth to multiple other devices, but unless the last device they were used with isn't around or isn't powered off - its been a huge hassle to swap. You have to find the device disconnect them and turn off bluetooth on the device they were connected to. Otherwise they'll stay connected to the old device and not connect to the device you want them to. So hassle / limitation #1.

Next, with the Anker Soundcore only the right earpiece can be used independently. The left will not function with out the right. The Airpods instead function independently of each other. You can use the left or the right airpod individually. So hassle / limitation #2.

The usable range for the Soundcore away from your device paired device is way smaller. Hassle / limitation #3.

Then, when you step too far away, the Soundcore loose connection, and then step back (returning in rage) -- The Anker Soundcore don't reconnect well, if at all. And you lose the left earpiece. To reconnect the left, you have to either redock both earpiece or on the connected device entirely disconnect and reconnect them (but it didn't always work, necessitating redocking both). Hassle / limitation #4.

No auto-pause on the Soundcore when either the left or right "pod" is taken out of the ear. Hassle / limitation #5.

Another large criticism against the AirPods are how they are limited to a single doubletap on either "pod" to start/stop, skip next, skip previous, or summon Siri. And only get to choose two of those. So, again, 3rd party engineers that aren't limited like Apple to the rescue again, right? Well, the Soundcore have no effective usable on earpiece operation. The Anker soundcore instructions say I can tap or touch or swipe or something to pause music, skip track (back or forward), or raise and lower volume it, but it never worked for me. Maybe mine were defective. Hassle / limitation #6

Now, sound wise they Soundcore were much better since they were in-ear sealed vs Airpods on-ear open design. So finally a win for the Soundcore.

That said, for the above reasons: They were no competitor. I could have paid $130 - $160 for the Jabra True Wireless earbuds - But I though we supposed to be able to get functionally equivalent or superior true wireless 'buds' or 'pods' or earphones for half the price, which the Jabra are not.
 
Last edited:
I hear you, and it's important to understand that the features you attribute to the AIrpod are common on competitors going for as little as $50. The only thing you've mentioned that the Airpods do that someone else doesn't is not requiring a silicone tip.
Which $50 competitors have the stereo/mono feature along with tap and no hassle software installation? I’m not debating I can’t get a pair of b/t headphones for less.
 
Which $50 competitors have the stereo/mono feature along with tap and no hassle software installation? I’m not debating I can’t get a pair of b/t headphones for less.

I think you're grossly over valuing the difficulty of pairing. You do it once... and it's three steps instead of one. Anyway, these fit the bill.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07TKGWN3...337516e6a120caa4c40c4140109175&language=en_US

For a little more, the Creative Outlier AIr blow the Airpods (and frankly, Powerbeats) out of the water. https://www.amazon.com/Creative-Swe...e+outlier+air&qid=1567569987&s=gateway&sr=8-3

And if I am going to spend $200, I'm getting the Sony WF-1000XM3, widely considered the best earbuds on the market. In fact, I did get them... i'm wearing them now. https://www.amazon.com/Sony-WF-1000...0076&s=gateway&sprefix=wf,aps,416&sr=8-3&th=1
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
I think you're grossly over valuing the difficulty of pairing. You do it once... and it's three steps instead of one. Anyway, these fit the bill.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07TKGWN3...337516e6a120caa4c40c4140109175&language=en_US

For a little more, the Creative Outlier AIr blow the Airpods (and frankly, Powerbeats) out of the water. https://www.amazon.com/Creative-Swe...e+outlier+air&qid=1567569987&s=gateway&sr=8-3

And if I am going to spend $200, I'm getting the Sony WF-1000XM3, widely considered the best earbuds on the market. In fact, I did get them... i'm wearing them now. https://www.amazon.com/Sony-WF-1000XM3-Industry-Canceling-Wireless/dp/B07T81554H/ref=sr_1_3?crid=20M51UMK5YFG2&keywords=wf-1000xm3&qid=1567570076&s=gateway&sprefix=wf,aps,416&sr=8-3&th=1
I don’t want silicon tips. I like the ability to use either ear, or both. I’m after convenience and not absolute sound quality.

As far as the xm3 I have the qc 35 II. They were more comfortable to me and support two device pairings. The xm3s don’t. Ymmv.

edit: during the day I walk around with my phone in my pocket and one airpod in a pocket.

When the phone rings I easily get the airpod and insert into ear and answer the phone with a double tap on the pod. That’s the convenience I was referring to.
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
My daughter when I told her I was getting the AirPods 2 when they came out, "they are just a status symbol; they look like q-tips, they will make you look goofy." My daughter, when she came over this weekend, "I think I want a pair of AirPods." Headed straight to the nearest Micro Center and got her a pair at $30 off. She didn't even wait to get home before putting them on.
 
I think you're grossly over valuing the difficulty of pairing. You do it once... and it's three steps instead of one.
If you’re only connecting to one single device, sure. How is switching between two devices or more devices? Is Bluetooth flexible these days, this way? I found you could pair the Anker Soundcore headphones to multiple devices. But, you couldn't just go to the device you want and say connect please. If was still connected or if the other paired device is still around and powered on - my experience was you had to go turn that device off first. It was a pain.

Just seamlessly move to the device I want you connected to. Pairing to new devices every time was a pain too. Once and done with Apple.

Now I’ve enjoyed and viewed Anker products as quality in the past. And if you only had one device and didn't care about the other nice features - they were just fine for $80 - quality even. But missing those really nice qualify of life features.

I’ll give those $50 ones you recommend a try - $44, after coupon and 5% discount.

Simplicity in switching to paired devices is key and maintaining the other features necessary, too. Less then $50 is cheap, but if it's missing anything then it is you pay for what you get.

And if I am going to spend $200, I'm getting the Sony WF-1000XM3, widely considered the best earbuds on the market. In fact, I did get them... i'm wearing them now. https://www.amazon.com/Sony-WF-1000XM3-Industry-Canceling-Wireless/dp/B07T81554H/ref=sr_1_3?crid=20M51UMK5YFG2&keywords=wf-1000xm3&qid=1567570076&s=gateway&sprefix=wf,aps,416&sr=8-3&th=1
And they’re $230 dollars. But, correct me if wrong, it seems to me like you’re saying that you’re willing to pay 40% extra for specific features, capabilities, or performance. Which seems to be the same that you’re criticizing AirPods owners for.

If those $50 “buds” you linked me to function equivalently to AirPods then your criticisms are valid. But I have my skepticisms.
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
  • Like
Reactions: I7guy
The point i'm trying to make about airpods is that they are fine. They do what they do fine, but they don't excel at anything except pairing, a process most of us do once. They also appeal to the unusual use case of not wanting silicone tips. That's all fine...They are like a Toyota Corolla. My problem is that they are priced like a Lexus. For $100 they are a good value... anything over that and you can very likely do better.
 
That’s the point, depending on what your looking for you can’t do better. The sound quality is good, the features can’t be beat. Worth every penny to me and it appears many others since Apple couldn’t keep them in stock for a time. Clearly personal preferences here, nothing wrong with that. Different strokes for different folks.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.