Your photographs (thank you for posting them) really show how over the last decade Apple have managed to squeeze in more power and a marginally larger screen into a smaller package. I had not appreciated the changes to the screen thickness either.
Around 2012 I was lugging around a five-year-old black plastic MacBook and had my eyes on the Pro series; the Air didn't appeal then and I never really looked at them. These days the 2013 rMBP is being phased out while the M2 MBA comes on-stream.
I do not think your spec choice is controversial at all, but then I am subject to my own views and biases...
Around 2012 I was lugging around a five-year-old black plastic MacBook and had my eyes on the Pro series; the Air didn't appeal then and I never really looked at them. These days the 2013 rMBP is being phased out while the M2 MBA comes on-stream.
I do not think your spec choice is controversial at all, but then I am subject to my own views and biases...