Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

FlyinPig

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 12, 2008
7
0
When using the built in keyboard in Garageband:
Is middle C, C4 or C3? I'm confused.

=)
 
C3 is middle C in Logic's piano roll view. I assume it's the same in Garageband(?)

You could always draw a C3 note in piano roll view and then switch to notation view and see if the note is between the two staffs.

oddly enough, C3 seems to be middle C. I wonder why they did that.

Because you learn middle C is C3 if you study music as an art. ;)

Although the scientific pitch notation system uses middle C = C4, within the world of Western music middle C = C3.

To further confuse the issue, because the MIDI standard does not specify a particular octave numbering, different types of MIDI keyboards by different manufacturers may label either C4, C5, or C3 as middle C (note 60).
 
Yeah. I'd always been taught C4 to be middle C. That's why I thought it was strange. I had to check on here just in case I was going mad. XD
 
If I remember correctly: In Calkwalk Sonar middle C = C5. In Apple's Logic and Steinberg's Cubase middle C = C3. Digidesign's ProTools lets the user select either C3, C4, or C5 as a label for middle C. On Roland and Kurzweil MIDI keyboards middle C = C4. On Yamaha MIDI keyboards middle C = C3. And so on...

It really isn't the problem it might seem to be, because MIDI note #60 = middle C. What middle C is labeled or called (C3 vs. C4 vs. C5, etc.) is largely a cosmetic issue.
 
C3 is middle C in Logic's piano roll view. I assume it's the same in Garageband(?)

You could always draw a C3 note in piano roll view and then switch to notation view and see if the note is between the two staffs.



Because you learn middle C is C3 if you study music as an art. ;)

Although the scientific pitch notation system uses middle C = C4, within the world of Western music middle C = C3.

To further confuse the issue, because the MIDI standard does not specify a particular octave numbering, different types of MIDI keyboards by different manufacturers may label either C4, C5, or C3 as middle C (note 60).

first post for me in the forums and this article was interesting, cheers for that as I have wondered in the past when using logic.
p.s glad to see some people aren't as sarcastic as the first replier ;)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.