Monitor help for MBP

toxic

macrumors 68000
Nov 9, 2008
1,664
1
that's a TN panel. I suggest you look for PVA or IPS panels instead, otherwise spend the extra for one of the better hardware colorimeters, since this seems to be one of the better TN panels. though I guess I should add that I don't think glossy screens work very well for photography.
 

zachsilvey

macrumors 6502
Feb 5, 2008
444
3
Battle Ground
that's a TN panel. I suggest you look for PVA or IPS panels instead, otherwise spend the extra for one of the better hardware colorimeters, since this seems to be one of the better TN panels. though I guess I should add that I don't think glossy screens work very well for photography.
As they said, glossy screens are not good for photography. If you do get two monitors you need a hardware calibrator because no two monitors are the same. If you wanted to drive a second external monitor from your MBP you could do it with one of the USB devices but you would get horrible performance and it wouldn't play well with pro apps.
 

bcgflow

macrumors newbie
Oct 25, 2009
8
0
You'll also need to buy the extra dvi dongle to connect to the monitor. Like posters above said you can only support one (i'm using my MBP with an external monitor, wish I could use 2 external monitors myself)
 

DAM-Photography

macrumors member
Original poster
May 10, 2009
64
0
Thanks everyone. I guess I will only be getting one of them then. Which screens did you end up going for on your MBP? Glossy or antiglare?
Also what is the best way to connect the MBP to the monitor?
 

Jaro65

macrumors 68040
Mar 27, 2009
3,711
593
Seattle, WA
I definitely prefer matte screen to glossy. The latter one really makes the colors pop, but the reflections could be difficult to control.
 

jaysen

macrumors 6502
Sep 16, 2009
272
2
Like everyone else has stated, i'll add my .2 cents to reiterate;

Definitely go with an IPS or PVA panel at minimum. Do not settle for a TN panel - period. If you're set on HP, consider the LP2475W - it's an S-IPS panel with great color reproduction. The set will set you back $450-600 depending on where you purchase from but definitely worth the money.

Other Suggestions are the Dell U2410, NEC EA231WMi, or the Dell 2209WA (using 2 in a Dual Set-Up).

Either of these monitors would be a truly huge step-up from what you're considering.

Don't forget to invest in a calibration unit - EyeOne LT or similar.

Also, buy the Genuine miniDP to DVI adapter when hooking these monitors up - I purchased some monoprice adapters and all though they worked great for the cost, I did notice some noise at higher resolutions (1920x1080)
 

DAM-Photography

macrumors member
Original poster
May 10, 2009
64
0
I'm not sure exactly what I'm looking for here. Here is the list of monitors I can get.
HPQ 1 A W22 22"W LCD 22" Wide LCD $120.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 6 C W22 22"W LCD 22" Wide LCD $110.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 3 C W2207 22" BLACK 22" Wide LCD $140.00 90 DAYS
GATEWAY 2 C FPD2275W 22" Wide LCD $130.00 90 DAYS
GATEWAY 1 C HD2201e 22" Wide LCD $110.00 90 DAYS
Gateway 1 A HD 2200 22" W 22" Wide LCD $120.00 90 DAYS
Gateway 3 C HD 2200 22" W 22" Wide LCD $110.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 11 A W2338H 23" Wide LCD $180.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 21 C W2338H 23" Wide LCD $170.00 90 DAYS
GATEWAY 2 C FHD2400 24" LCD 24" Wide LCD $190.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 4 C W2408 24" 24" Wide LCD $190.00 90 DAYS

Would any of these be worth while or would you recommend me different monitor?
 

jaysen

macrumors 6502
Sep 16, 2009
272
2
I'm not sure exactly what I'm looking for here. Here is the list of monitors I can get.
HPQ 1 A W22 22"W LCD 22" Wide LCD $120.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 6 C W22 22"W LCD 22" Wide LCD $110.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 3 C W2207 22" BLACK 22" Wide LCD $140.00 90 DAYS
GATEWAY 2 C FPD2275W 22" Wide LCD $130.00 90 DAYS
GATEWAY 1 C HD2201e 22" Wide LCD $110.00 90 DAYS
Gateway 1 A HD 2200 22" W 22" Wide LCD $120.00 90 DAYS
Gateway 3 C HD 2200 22" W 22" Wide LCD $110.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 11 A W2338H 23" Wide LCD $180.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 21 C W2338H 23" Wide LCD $170.00 90 DAYS
GATEWAY 2 C FHD2400 24" LCD 24" Wide LCD $190.00 90 DAYS
HPQ 4 C W2408 24" 24" Wide LCD $190.00 90 DAYS

Would any of these be worth while or would you recommend me different monitor?
All of those monitors (unless I've overlooked them) use TN panels - Not worth it IMO.

If size/budget is what you're looking for I highly, highly, suggest the Dell 2209WA - an IPS panel that can be had for $210/shipped + tax (for some)...

I know this thread is a few weeks old but never saw the reply
 

toxic

macrumors 68000
Nov 9, 2008
1,664
1
I'm not sure exactly what I'm looking for here. Here is the list of monitors I can get.

...

Would any of these be worth while or would you recommend me different monitor?
you can check the panel type here: http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/

a giveaway for IPS panels is a 178 degree viewing angle and maybe a slow response time, around 15 ms. if you can see it in person, IPS panels give a purple color cast in the blacks when viewed at an extreme angle. TN panels turn yellow. I dunno about PVA.
 

Similar threads

  • BJMRamage
11
Replies
11
Views
979
  • Apple_Glen_UK
1
Replies
1
Views
471
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
643
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.