$25 for 2GB of data is something quite different from $30 for all one can consume.
Can we at least pretend to be honest in this debate?
My last effort here.
Look, in principle I think such a device would be fantastic, I just don't see it being realistic even if Apple wanted to manufacture it. Maybe I'm underestimating the ability of the At&T network. Maybe I'm reading too much into the fact that telecoms from AT&T to O2 to Sonera are promoting the use of wifi hotspots in addition to 3G broadband. Maybe I'm underestimating Apple's willingness to release a device and let all consumers (even in the US) fool around with APNs and find their own microsim cards.
But, I just don't see how in a period where conventional wisdom is that AT&T is losing exclusivity on the iPhone that they are willingly going to offer cheap data to millions of iPhone-like devices that are going to be streaming netflix all day and tax the network.
So let's assume that there is a figurative big red button at Foxconn that can be hit to start manufacturing a 32GB iPod touch with 3G/GPS, Retina display, and two cameras all for the price of $450; it won't happen unless Jobs can get on stage and say "We have reached an agreement with AT&T to extend the breakthrough 3G pricing that iPad customers enjoy to iPod touch customers."
This is not about trying not to offend current iPhone customers. This is also not about intentionally treating iPod touch customers as second class citizens. Everybody would probably love cheaper data with fewer contracts.
This is about a rumor that states: "the company [Apple] has strongly considered mimicking its iPad offerings by adding a 3G option to some of its iPod touch portable media players, though it is unclear whether the Cupertino-based company has decided to proceed with those plans..."
Of course Apple would strongly consider such a move as it is in its long-term benefit to reduce 3G broadband to a dumb pipe. Despite unlocked devices such as the iPad, Apple has always had mobile partners. I doubt there's a willing telecom partner for such a device.