I like your idea, that's pretty much what I was going for. I don't know why people seem to enjoy making 30 different threads on one subject. Like "0mGz!! New iPhone this summer, should I wait or get the 3G?". Oh well
I thought that thread was good, the only knock I had on it was you wanting it to be a sticky.
Perhaps it got moved to to the wasteland because you were the only one posting all of the links to the same thread by a different person. IDK
I would also put in a vote to get it out of there, but then even if it was brought back to life, how many people would post there stories there?
I mean why do you think there are so many of the "cracked screen and story threads" and "should I get a new phone now or wait threads"? I think anyone who creates the thread wants their own personal attention on the matter.
But then again the "post your iphone's wallpaper" and "the iphone photo of the day" threads all have had great success.