Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

N9JIG

macrumors regular
Original poster
I have had several standing desks over the years. Starting out with a cheap ($130) Ikea model for the wife and her MacBook Pro/Cal Digit TS4 dock and a single 32” monitor it works fine and we have had it for 8 years. For a while it was relegated to the garage as the controller would only allow it to go up, to move it down required a small wrench to turn the hex-shaped motion bar. I eventually took the controller apart and repaired the switch (bad solder joint) and now it works fine.

My next standing desk was an Office Depot “Magellan” desk. This was fairly inexpensive ($369 at the time) and with free delivery it was a great deal. It took less than an hour to assemble and it turned out to be a nice, sturdy basic desk. At 30” deep and 60” wide it has plenty of desktop space. It has an inch-thick laminated MDF desk surface and steel frame; The motor unit has a built-in outlet strip with 2 USB power ports. The wife liked it so much she bought one for her sewing room (and still has it!) I replaced it with the next entry here and the wife used it for a second assembly table in her sewing room before the daughter-in-law claimed it for herself, she took it with her when they moved out and still uses it. I like it just fine but needed more space.

My next desk was an Uplift jumbo-sized L-shaped standing desk. This was a real behemoth, but it was perfect for my needs. At the time I had 3 monitors plus a 27” iMac Pro, later replaced by a Mac Mini, then a MacBook Pro and now a Studio. I also had various ham radios, a Windows computer and accessories. The Uplift was a great desk and I really liked it. I never had a problem with it mechanically or operationally. After I retired from the WFH job I really did not need as elaborate a system, but the kid was moving in and I was going to share an office with him. He also worked from home in an IT job and needed more space than I did so I reverted back to one of the Magellan’s for a while and gave him the Uplift. He liked it so much that when they moved into their new home, they took it with them and he uses it still.

For my radios I bought a utilitarian Home Depot workbench type crank-up. This has 2 tool drawers underneath. It was actually my wife’s idea, she liked the aesthetics of it, she had seen similar stuff used at her hair salon and though it would work well for me. I agreed and we went to Home Depot and bought one. I already had a slightly smaller one in white in the garage for a real work bench and I figured I would use the new black one for the radios and can repurpose it later for an additional workbench (Spoiler: I did.)

My biggest pet peeve is wire management. I cannot stand to see wires. With multiple monitors, 2 computers, 25 radios and various other tech there are a ton of wires in my office. That’s where the latest desk came in. I saw some sponsored YouTube videos about the new SecretLab Magnus Pro standing desk. It really looked intriguing. It has a wire tray along the back and a flip lid to cover it. There is just enough space between the desk surface and wire tray for cables to pop in and out as well as a boatload of accessories like monitor mounts, computer mounts and magnetic wire clips. The entire desk, including the desktop, is heavy grade steel, the desktop had an MDF core under the steel. They have various desktop mats, held down magnetically, that covers the entire desktop with a mousing surface and to protect from scratches. I had to have one and ordered it on that Wednesday. It was expensive (about $1500 with the accessories I bought) but would be worth it, so I thought.

It arrived on Saturday morning. I had to leave but when I returned the kid had already assembled it for me. He said it took about half an hour. I spent an hour or so setting up the computer, monitors (3) and accessories. I bought 2 of the dual monitor arms, I only needed 3 monitors at the time, but I figured I could always add a 4th later this way. I also ordered 2 of the under-desk CPU mounts, These are pretty neat, they hold a full-sized computer case under the desk along either leg. I bought one for the PC and the second for a UPS.

This has been the best desk I have had. The black color scheme matches the aesthetic in my office, it is extremely sturdy and the wire management tray is awesome. I had an outlet strip, USB power brick and a whole bunch of wires hidden in there. The integrated power connection allows for a single power cable to be attached to the leg; there is an outlet in the tray for your power strip. There is plenty of room in the tray for things like a small Ethernet hub, USB hub, power blocks and other stuff that does not need to be on the desk. On my desk I have that power cable coming out the leg and an Ethernet cable coming down the back leg, hidden by magnetic sheaths. I would go WIFI, but I now have 2GB fiber to the house and I cannot get the full speed over WIFI.

So, after the kid moved out and I had the office to myself again I was using the SecretLab desk for my computers and the Home Depot workbench for the radios. It worked fine but I really liked the SecretLab desk so much I wanted to get a second one for the radios. I ordered one up and a couple days later it arrived. It took me about a half hour or so to assemble it and an hour so to set up the radio cabinet and wiring. I moved the PC to that desk along with one of the monitor arms (happy now that I bought 2!) and got it all working.

For the last year this has been my setup. The Mac and a couple monitors (or a single 49” widescreen) on one and my Windows machine and radios with a couple monitors (and now the same 49” widescreen) on the other. The only thing that I could see replacing this setup is if SecretLab came out with an L-shaped version with the same wire trays.
 
I have had several standing desks over the years. Starting out with a cheap ($130) Ikea model for the wife and her MacBook Pro/Cal Digit TS4 dock and a single 32” monitor it works fine and we have had it for 8 years. For a while it was relegated to the garage as the controller would only allow it to go up, to move it down required a small wrench to turn the hex-shaped motion bar. I eventually took the controller apart and repaired the switch (bad solder joint) and now it works fine.

My next standing desk was an Office Depot “Magellan” desk. This was fairly inexpensive ($369 at the time) and with free delivery it was a great deal. It took less than an hour to assemble and it turned out to be a nice, sturdy basic desk. At 30” deep and 60” wide it has plenty of desktop space. It has an inch-thick laminated MDF desk surface and steel frame; The motor unit has a built-in outlet strip with 2 USB power ports. The wife liked it so much she bought one for her sewing room (and still has it!) I replaced it with the next entry here and the wife used it for a second assembly table in her sewing room before the daughter-in-law claimed it for herself, she took it with her when they moved out and still uses it. I like it just fine but needed more space.

My next desk was an Uplift jumbo-sized L-shaped standing desk. This was a real behemoth, but it was perfect for my needs. At the time I had 3 monitors plus a 27” iMac Pro, later replaced by a Mac Mini, then a MacBook Pro and now a Studio. I also had various ham radios, a Windows computer and accessories. The Uplift was a great desk and I really liked it. I never had a problem with it mechanically or operationally. After I retired from the WFH job I really did not need as elaborate a system, but the kid was moving in and I was going to share an office with him. He also worked from home in an IT job and needed more space than I did so I reverted back to one of the Magellan’s for a while and gave him the Uplift. He liked it so much that when they moved into their new home, they took it with them and he uses it still.

For my radios I bought a utilitarian Home Depot workbench type crank-up. This has 2 tool drawers underneath. It was actually my wife’s idea, she liked the aesthetics of it, she had seen similar stuff used at her hair salon and though it would work well for me. I agreed and we went to Home Depot and bought one. I already had a slightly smaller one in white in the garage for a real work bench and I figured I would use the new black one for the radios and can repurpose it later for an additional workbench (Spoiler: I did.)

My biggest pet peeve is wire management. I cannot stand to see wires. With multiple monitors, 2 computers, 25 radios and various other tech there are a ton of wires in my office. That’s where the latest desk came in. I saw some sponsored YouTube videos about the new SecretLab Magnus Pro standing desk. It really looked intriguing. It has a wire tray along the back and a flip lid to cover it. There is just enough space between the desk surface and wire tray for cables to pop in and out as well as a boatload of accessories like monitor mounts, computer mounts and magnetic wire clips. The entire desk, including the desktop, is heavy grade steel, the desktop had an MDF core under the steel. They have various desktop mats, held down magnetically, that covers the entire desktop with a mousing surface and to protect from scratches. I had to have one and ordered it on that Wednesday. It was expensive (about $1500 with the accessories I bought) but would be worth it, so I thought.

It arrived on Saturday morning. I had to leave but when I returned the kid had already assembled it for me. He said it took about half an hour. I spent an hour or so setting up the computer, monitors (3) and accessories. I bought 2 of the dual monitor arms, I only needed 3 monitors at the time, but I figured I could always add a 4th later this way. I also ordered 2 of the under-desk CPU mounts, These are pretty neat, they hold a full-sized computer case under the desk along either leg. I bought one for the PC and the second for a UPS.

This has been the best desk I have had. The black color scheme matches the aesthetic in my office, it is extremely sturdy and the wire management tray is awesome. I had an outlet strip, USB power brick and a whole bunch of wires hidden in there. The integrated power connection allows for a single power cable to be attached to the leg; there is an outlet in the tray for your power strip. There is plenty of room in the tray for things like a small Ethernet hub, USB hub, power blocks and other stuff that does not need to be on the desk. On my desk I have that power cable coming out the leg and an Ethernet cable coming down the back leg, hidden by magnetic sheaths. I would go WIFI, but I now have 2GB fiber to the house and I cannot get the full speed over WIFI.

So, after the kid moved out and I had the office to myself again I was using the SecretLab desk for my computers and the Home Depot workbench for the radios. It worked fine but I really liked the SecretLab desk so much I wanted to get a second one for the radios. I ordered one up and a couple days later it arrived. It took me about a half hour or so to assemble it and an hour so to set up the radio cabinet and wiring. I moved the PC to that desk along with one of the monitor arms (happy now that I bought 2!) and got it all working.

For the last year this has been my setup. The Mac and a couple monitors (or a single 49” widescreen) on one and my Windows machine and radios with a couple monitors (and now the same 49” widescreen) on the other. The only thing that I could see replacing this setup is if SecretLab came out with an L-shaped version with the same wire trays.
I love mechanized standing desks as well. My wife and I have two - one in my office and one in hers. Both of ours came from Costco - I think the maker/model was Tresanti/Geller but dont hold me to that lol. Anyways, mine is black rectangular with a glass top, touch sensitive height controls, drawer and usb-a charging hub. My wifes is the newer iteration of mine and is white with a slight stomach cut/curve, same glass type with touch controls and mixed usb-a/c charging hub.

These have served us very well with sturdy, tig welded, steel and glass construction. No chinsy laminate, particle board, or plastic materials in it. I would consider an L shape if I could find one that matches my current desk in design asthetic and quality.
 
There's a number of stand desk threads here, I think overall they were a bit of a fad a number of years ago, now they're not so popular.

I'm not saying they're useful, or don't have health benefits, but overall ergnomically I think people by and large will want to sit to work. It seems much more comfortable to sit and type then stand and type, but that may be a personal preference.

Overall its great that you and others found something very helpful, but I think overall its not something the masses want to use.
 
The one disadvantage to the SecretLab Magnus desks that I have come directly from one of their biggest advantages. The integrated controller protects itself from being sheared off or injuring ones thigh by being integrated into the desktop itself.

The disadvantage though means you cannot replace the desktop with a custom surface like the others. My kid who took my UpLift uses a second desk for gaming, where he bought a frame and had a custom "River" desk made by a woodworker. Look up Blacktail Studios on YouTube for the style.

I found that the biggest advantage to the standing desk is that I can raise it to work on things, pulling it out from the wall and bringing it to height allows me to stand comfortably at the rear to set up monitors etc. Being 6'4" it saves me from a lot of stooping.

I do work from time to time in a standing position, usually for a half hour once or twice a day. Also being able to adjust the table height a little when seated is nice to vary things a little. Sometimes I like to rest my elbows on my seat arms, or I will move the keyboard a bit further back on the desk and rest them on the desk surface. Being able to adjust the table height makes it more comfortable to type, kick back with a movie, or edit images.

I would consider an L shape if I could find one that matches my current desk in design asthetic and quality.
Check out Uplift at: https://www.upliftdesk.com/l-shaped-and-corner-desks/ I can vouch for the quality and you can customize the frames and surfaces to your needs. My SecretLab system does not allow that type of customization. I had also looked at Lander before I bought my Uplift, really nice but more expensive, I think I did better with the Uplift.

One thing that startled me with both the Uplift and the SecretLab was the condition of the shipping boxes when they arrived. They were totally beat up, taped all over and looked like they were tossed around from truck to truck. I took photos as I was sure the stuff inside would have been severely damaged. Not even a scratch on any of them! They were really well packed and protected. SecretLab has been called out by several reviewers for excessive packing materials but their product is heavy and the dense foam they are packed in does a great job protecting the product from damage. Would you prefer a damaged desk or a bit more waste?

BTW, we almost bought one of those Costco desks a while back for the wife. They look nice and were just the right size. I don't remember why we passed on it at the time though.
 
Generally, I prefer to stand and walk around as I work, so the adjustable standing desk design is perfect for me. I probably stand 4-6 hrs of an 8hr workday on average but easily can pace my way to 8hrs haha.

The downside of this desk is like yours - the controls are touch capacitance & accessed through the glass. This makes covering it impossible. Unless you lock it, it’s easy to hit the controls and change your height adjustment accidentally. Additionally, optical mice won’t track on the glass so for gaming, this is a problem unless you add a mouse pad which I am not a fan off. I however use a trackball at this desk so that is a non our for me.

Still, an excellent desk that I hope lasts me forever.
 
Yeah, I think the mousing issue was one of the factors in not getting it. The SecretLab has a full-desktop mousing surface. The controller has an off-switch so that helps prevent accidental movements. It is integrated into the front face of the desktop, not the surface so that means it won't be in the way of the mouse.

I had a desktop with a glass top at work, I had to replace my mouse with an old-fashioned roller ball model we dug up out of the junk pile. I too hate mouse pads, they are always to restrictive. I showed this thread to the wife and she remembers seeing that desk and if it shows up again at Costco one of these days I would not be surprised if she gets one!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.