I would also recommend the Epson R300 or R320 - they deliver excellent quality and are also very well made for the price. I also like the fact that their color cartridges are split out (CMYK, I believe?) and they have pretty good ink usage.
~~soapbox~~
I would avoid the HPs these days. They used to make nice consumer printers and scanners, imho, but seems like since they merged with Compaq (may be related, or may just be matter of circumstance), their quality has tanked. Everything feels very cheap and clunky. Plus, they have new smaller ink cartridges that seem like they're half the size of the ones on their older models, yet they cost 2/3 as much. So, you end up dropping twenty bucks on ink seemingly constantly. 😡 I have no idea if their commercial / officejet products have also suffered.
~~off soapbox~~