Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Nbd1790

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 2, 2017
353
279
New York
I recently moved and used the last generation Airport Extreme as my only Wifi device and it worked incredibly well in a 3 story townhouse. The new house I'm in is considerably wider than my previous home, and the router is placed all the way in the right side of the house (not by choice) as opposed to the center in my old house.

The problem I'm having is on the left side of the house, and the basement (a ranch house with a basement). I plugged in my airport extreme, get my usual speed (typically 200 MBps download). Once I start entering the basement, the wifi signal drops off a cliff. There's an average of 1/2 bars of signal, but speeds are HORRIBLE. Averaging anywhere from 6-12 MBps. I figured id keep the setup as simple as possible and purchased a used airport express to extend the wifi signal. The signal itself became more stable, but now the extender averages 6-20 MBps if I'm lucky. My goal is to get roughly 100 MBps throughout the house. I'm the only one who lives here so I don't need a crazy number.

I can't / don't want to run a hardwire throughout the house, as my experience with IT in this area has been horrible and they always try and take shortcuts, so it worries me that they'll do some excessive damage. I'm looking at the standard eero mesh router system. So my question is does anyone have this system? And if so, would it be connected the way I would have it? Which would be one eero hardwired to the modem, then place the other two throughout the house (not hardwired). As I mentioned, I'm more concerned about the speed being consistent 100+ throughout the house. I only pay for 200 MBps, so I'm ruling out the eero pro system despite its excellent reviews.

Any insight would be appreciated! Just want to see if an eero mesh system would essentially leave me in the same situation I'm in now, or improve my system speed / coverage overall. Thanks!
 
I tried a couple different mesh systems. First I tried AMPLIFI. That worked ok, but then after a software update it started to go haywire, and i never got it working reliability again after a couple of months of trying. I then moved on to Synology. It is incredibly powerful, my speeds are double what i got out of the AMPLIFI, and it’s been pretty reliable. It’s not cheap, and it’s interface is a little unfriendly, but it works.

I hear good things about eero, fwiw, but my house was a little complicated (mix of cat6 cables and wifi extensions) so i went with the more powerful solution.
 
Hide a long ethernet cord along the wall / under the carpet and run a second Airport Extreme in the underserved area?

I know, I know...... Give up on the AE.... ? I happen to have good luck in buying used ones off ebay.

I just set up an AE 1521 model in a relatives house in wireless bridge mode in order to supply wireless signal outside the house to a location "far away" from the existing pirmary Airport. Worked really well for connectivity. They don't have a huge need for speed though.
 
For my router, I use a Netgear R7000 Nighthawk. Seems rock-solid.
For NAS, I use a Synology NAS (a DS412+ ) ... running 4tb x 4 = 16tb RAID-5

If you don't want to spring for a real NAS, I'm pretty sure you can just connect a USB-HDD directly to the R7000.

The rest is:
Netgear CM600 Cable Modem (but your ISP might give you a cable-modem)
Netgear GS728TPv2 Managed 24-Port Switch (but smaller Netgear Pro-Safe ethernet Switches are also good and reliable)
 
Decided to go with a new WiFi system. Went with the EERO mesh system and it worked wonders. I pay for 200MBPS download through my provider. I get the full 200+ from my main EERO router (same as with the extreme). The deadzone I had was getting roughly 7-10MBPS. With the new system in place, the entire basement now gets 100+ at any given point. I would highly recommend to anyone who needs a decent coverage and decent speed.
 
super long eithernet cable might work good, or get a few Wi-fi repeaters, or (EOP eithernet-over-power) if you have a spare power socket out there.
 
If you do go with a mesh system such as the Eero or Orbi, make sure it is compatible with your ISPs service. Up here, the Orbi is the only one that works with all of the local ISPs, as the type of authentication both MTA and ATT use is apparently nut supported by other brands of Mesh networking.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.