Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

nope7308

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Oct 6, 2008
1,040
537
Ontario, Canada
Roughly, here is my existing plan:
- 200 daytime minutes
- 75 long distance minutes
- 250 outgoing text messages, unlimited incoming
- Voicemail 10
- Caller ID, call waiting, etc.
- Free evenings and weekends beginning at 6pm

This costs exactly $20/month after tax. I never exceed the voice/text limit.

If I purchase an iPhone through my existing carrier, I have to sign an iPhone contract. For a comparable iPhone plan that includes 500MB of data, I’m looking at approximately $60/month (not including 75 long distance minutes). So, I was thinking of being a little sly…

As an alternative, I can buy the iPhone directly from Apple, and then add data to my existing plan. The cheapest data add-on is $10/month, which gives you 100MB. If you exceed 100MB, you are then charged $20/month up to 250MB. I suspect the total cost would be about $35/month, plus the cost of the phone (assuming I don’t exceed 100MB). Through monthly savings, it would take me a little less than 2 years to offset the subsidized price of the phone.

The advantage of the data add-on strategy is that I won’t be locked under contract, plus I will have an additional 75 long distance minutes. The initial cost of the phone would be substantially higher, but this would be offset in 2 years rather than 3. The other downside, by my lights, is that I would never be eligible for an upgrade through my carrier because I’m not on an iPhone contract. In other words, if I wanted to buy the iPhone 5, I would have to pay full price again (but no contract, and a cheaper monthly rate).

SOOOOOOOOO…

I need some reassurance that the data add-on strategy is the most effective. I’m assuming I can resell the iPhone 4S relatively easily, which should help to offset the initial cost of future phones. Do you think 100MB/month is a reasonable estimate of data consumption? I’ve never owned a smartphone before, so I don’t anticipate being a “heavy user”. That, and I’m almost always within range of a wifi network.

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated, and sorry for the novel!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.