Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mra1989

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 13, 2010
42
0
Virginia Beach
Ok let me start off by saying that I've yet to have an apple computer. I have had an iPhone ever since the release of the 3G. I love apple products thus far and I'm looking to purchase a laptop before I transfer to a 4 year university next year. I have a toshiba laptop now that my parents bought me when I graduated high school in 2007. Don't get me wrong the laptop was a nice gesture and it fulfilled it's purpose, but the notebook isn't in the least bit portable. Here's what I am looking for in a prospective notebook:


PORTABILITY
decent memory
reliable functioning
don't need 3D graphics, but at the same time I want something that's easy on the eyes
It's primarily going to be for note taking, iTunes, and general research via internet.
Not a gamer.

At first glance, I love the air. I've tinkered with it on several trips to the apple store, so I'm biased. What would your suggestions be for me given the information I've listed. Thanks
 
Air is great and the most portable but it lacks too many things, e.g. only 2GB RAM, only 5-hour battery life, only one USB etc, not forgetting the amazing trackpad MacBook and MBPs have.

I would either wait till MBA update or just jump for 13" MBP, it's VERY portable
 
Air is great and the most portable but it lacks too many things, e.g. only 2GB RAM, only 5-hour battery life, only one USB etc, not forgetting the amazing trackpad MacBook and MBPs have.

I would either wait till MBA update or just jump for 13" MBP, it's VERY portable

While I understand about all of the things the air lacks, I'm not in much need of too many of those extras. With that being said is there any word thus far concerning what the next update/version of the air will have?
 
While I understand about all of the things the air lacks, I'm not in much need of too many of those extras. With that being said is there any word thus far concerning what the next update/version of the air will have?

Nope, we don't even know when or even if there will be an updated any time soon... That's how Apple rolls.

That aside, while you're in not much need of too many "extras" you're better off getting that little bit more than what you need rather than what's "just right" cause needs change over time.

For a couple thousand dollar investment, you want something that's a little "future proof" in terms of a potentially evolving need.

Also, having a couple extra USB ports is far from an "extra" - it's really a standard. The Macbook Air is rather crippled in terms of features for a premium (given its age now) just for something that's needlessly thin really.
 
Good advice thus far. Anyone own a pro and an air that has a good compare and contrast on the two. I'm honestly not interested in the basic MacBook. Just a preference.
 
Sounds like the 13" is the best fit. However, if you can afford it I'd say get the 15" for the extra screen real estate, dedicated graphics card, and the i5. The C2D processor will be far outdated by the time your done with it, but the i5 won't be cutting edge either. I just got the i7 15" for college next year, and kinda wish I got the i5 since I don't do any heavy work to make room in the budget for the hi-res screen. But so far it seems plenty portable, but obviously not quite as much as a 13".
 
I would say the base 13" MBP, it is a good bit cheaper than the air, and you get a lot more: Double battery life, double memory, double HDD capacity, much better trackpad, faster processor, better graphics, internal superdrive, extra usb port, firewire 800, and an ethernet port, all for about a pound or pound and a half more weight. While you may not use all of that, much of it is very nice to have, especially the battery, which I think makes it even more portable than the air. I have the aluminum MacBook before they made it the pro, and it is basically the same computer. It is very nice to carry around, and is about the size and weight as a standard textbook.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.