NEED HELP! (Macbook Pro Gray screen)

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
It happened last night. First, I install a software which might not be compatible with Snow Leopard. Then, when I launched the app for the first time, my laptop froze and couldn't even execute force quit command. I did a restart. After seeing the apple logo, the start-up ended in a blank gray screen. The list below shows the things I've tried:

1. Snow Leopard disc boot: same gray screen.
2. Launching another SL via firewire: either gay screen or blue screen.
3. Safe mode: worked at the first few times, and I tried to reboot immediately but seeing the same gray screen again. I backed up important files in safe mode and did repair permissions(fixed a lot of problems that are related to safari) and verify HD (no problem found), but it didn't help.
4. Single user mode: launched and ran /sbin/fsck -fy few times till it said "The volume (name_of_volume) appears to be OK." However, this didn't help either.
5. This might has been a stupid thing that I've tried after the safe mode didn't even work anymore :) I took the HD out and formatted using a windows PC (i don't have another mac) and hope I can a fresh install. However, when starting up, all I can see now are first the gray screen (without apple logo) and then the black screen.

I took it to the genius bar, and they couldn't figured out why and want me to pay $310 flat rate to fix it. I just want to see if there's anything else I could try before spending $310. The laptop is a 17" core2due 2.33G model. I really appreciate any help, and thank you guys in advance.

Sorry about any misspellings and grammatical errors.
 

madog

macrumors 65816
Nov 25, 2004
1,274
1
Korova Milkbar
Are you able to boot up while holding down the OPTION key with a system disk inserted?

If you can boot up to it and launch Disk Utility, you should be able to format the drive if nothing else is wrong with it.
 

michaelfengdayu

macrumors member
Jun 22, 2007
71
0
Hardware test maybe?

Insert the disk that comes with your computer. Boot up while holding down "D". And see the result.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
Are you able to boot up while holding down the OPTION key with a system disk inserted?

If you can boot up to it and launch Disk Utility, you should be able to format the drive if nothing else is wrong with it.
you mean the cd? I've tried that. the cd shows up, but it gives me the same gray screen when boot form it.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
Insert the disk that comes with your computer. Boot up while holding down "D". And see the result.
thank you so much for helping.
I did that and something interesting happened: I see a blue screen instead when booting from the CD, and I can boot into the system on a external HD via firewire. What should I do now?
 

michaelfengdayu

macrumors member
Jun 22, 2007
71
0
thank you so much for helping.
I did that and something interesting happened: I see a blue screen instead when booting from the CD, and I can boot into the system on a external HD via firewire. What should I do now?
You can go to Disk Utility and reformat your HDD in your computer. But I would do a Hardware Test.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
btw, I thought power+command+ctrl can restart the macbook Pro, but it didn't work; it just shuts down.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
You can go to Disk Utility and reformat your HDD in your computer. But I would do a Hardware Test.
I reformatted the HD successfully, but the problem still exist. Booting from both the snow leopard disk and external HD shows the blue screen now.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
Any error messages in the Hardware Test?
I didn't run the test because I thought it only can be performed via the installation disc which gives the blue screen when booting. Can I run the test in safe mode?
 

michaelfengdayu

macrumors member
Jun 22, 2007
71
0
I didn't run the test because I thought it only can be performed via the installation disc which gives the blue screen when booting. Can I run the test in safe mode?
Insert the installation disk and power up while hold down the "D" key. It should go to the hardware test interface. If nothing happens, there might be some major problems in your computer. I suggest having a technician look at it.

PS: Make sure you use the original installation disk that came with the computer, not the Snow Leopard disk you bought later on.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
Insert the installation disk and power up while hold down the "D" key. It should go to the hardware test interface. If nothing happens, there might be some major problems in your computer. I suggest having a technician look at it.

PS: Make sure you use the original installation disk that came with the computer, not the Snow Leopard disk you bought later on.
Thank you for the tip again. I found the original system disk and passed the hardware test. I also pressed "C" when restarting after the test, and surprisingly it worked. Right now I am installing the original system, and I will see if this will resolve the problem.

Thanks for all you guys' help.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
Well, it passed the hardware test but the installation failed. I guess I have no other choice besides take it back to the genius bar.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
I am running the extended hardware test in loop mode now because I am little suspicious about the accuracy of past tests. The tests I ran were pretty fast. They took about 2-4 minuets only, and the testing message under the progress meter bar only showed memory and logic board. Does anyone know what the test result looks like?
 

michaelfengdayu

macrumors member
Jun 22, 2007
71
0
Your problem sounds a lot like my 4 yr old iBook when after I installed the system it hang up right before the welcome screen. More likely a graphic card problem. If it is the NVidia 8600GT, chances are you are still covered under warranty. BTW, which country are you in? the Genius you described doesn't sound very professional and they don't do a flat rate repair normally.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
Your problem sounds a lot like my 4 yr old iBook when after I installed the system it hang up right before the welcome screen. More likely a graphic card problem. If it is the NVidia 8600GT, chances are you are still covered under warranty. BTW, which country are you in? the Genius you described doesn't sound very professional and they don't do a flat rate repair normally.
Really? Interesting. I'm in the U.S.. Well, I don't even know what the real problem is now, how can I convince them the problem is the video card?
 

michaelfengdayu

macrumors member
Jun 22, 2007
71
0
Really? Interesting. I'm in the U.S.. Well, I don't even know what the real problem is now, how can I convince them the problem is the video card?
Go find another Genius, and they should be able to find what the problem is. By law, they have to provide support to the product.
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
I think that I do have video card related problem. After rebooting many times, I successfully login to Snow Leopard twice. however, both times ended in frozen screen not long after the login, and I notice there was a shadow of black lines under the mouse cursor. Can someone conform this for me? also, if it's the video card problem, is $310 flat rate a good deal to fix it (I don't have the Nvidia card)?
 

boch

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 3, 2009
13
0
Go find another Genius, and they should be able to find what the problem is. By law, they have to provide support to the product.
I think that I do have video card related problem. After rebooting many times, I successfully login to Snow Leopard twice. however, both times ended in frozen screen not long after the login, and I notice there was a shadow of black lines under the mouse cursor. Can someone conform this for me? also, if it's the video card problem, is $310 flat rate a good deal to fix it (I don't have the Nvidia card)?
 

michaelfengdayu

macrumors member
Jun 22, 2007
71
0
I think that I do have video card related problem. After rebooting many times, I successfully login to Snow Leopard twice. however, both times ended in frozen screen not long after the login, and I notice there was a shadow of black lines under the mouse cursor. Can someone conform this for me? also, if it's the video card problem, is $310 flat rate a good deal to fix it (I don't have the Nvidia card)?
I will tell you what I would do:

1) take a photo of the screen when strange image happens. This is for the evidence.
2) call the apple 800 number and explain the symptoms and ask them if you are covered if it's the graphic card problem. I remember it has an automatic 2 year warranty.
3) $310 is a good deal if you are out of luck and have to have your mother board replaced. The market price is over a grand.
 

filastine

macrumors newbie
Mar 22, 2011
2
0
Quick Direct Solution That Worked For Me

I registered just to post this, in case this should work for anyone else.

I installed a usb-internet mobile dongle thing, in this case if was Orange Italia. On restart all I could get was the gray screen and spinning wheel. I tried zapping P-RAM, PMU reset, connecting in target disc mode and doing repair permission, bought Disk Warrior and ran it on the disk, etc.. NOTHING WORKED.

Starting in safe mode didn't work either.

What worked is simply holding down the X key on startup. This is "force restart with mac os X". In my case the usb dongle must have put some pc crap on my machine and created confusion. I have no idea, but it worked.
Try it, it only takes a second.
 

Similar threads

Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.