Need some user opinions on Canon Lenses

[Edge100]

So, I think I've concluded that the ultimate in versatility for me will be my 35L f1.4 and a 24-105 f4 IS... this is a more expensive combo, but I have the 35L already. It may mean stuffing the 35L in a bag of some kind (backpack, GF's purse, etc.) but then I think you have the best of all worlds... a versatile zoom for landscape and snap-shots and the ultra fast prime for artistic shots and dark venues.

What do you think of this analysis/conclusion?

Interesting you should say this, as I've concluded the same thing for me.

I just got back from a trip to Beijing and Hong Kong, where I had a 5D2 and carried two of the following with me at all times:

- 35L
- 85L mkII
- Sigma 50 1.4
- 17-40

Now, don't get me wrong, I prefer primes, and I don't mind switching lenses (frankly, if I had my choice, I'd carry a second 5D2 and just use primes), but it becomes impractical for certain things.

I'm now convinced that adding a 24-105L is the way to go for this type of vacation travel, where I don't necessarily need all the benefits of primes, but still want good IQ. From now on, it'll be 5D2/24-105L/35L in my Billingham Hedley Small for travel, and the 85/50/17-40 will live in my Domke/Pelican back in the hotel.

 

[VirtualRain]

Interesting you should say this, as I've concluded the same thing for me.

I just got back from a trip to Beijing and Hong Kong, where I had a 5D2 and carried two of the following with me at all times:

- 35L
- 85L mkII
- Sigma 50 1.4
- 17-40

Now, don't get me wrong, I prefer primes, and I don't mind switching lenses (frankly, if I had my choice, I'd carry a second 5D2 and just use primes), but it becomes impractical for certain things.

I'm now convinced that adding a 24-105L is the way to go for this type of vacation travel, where I don't necessarily need all the benefits of primes, but still want good IQ. From now on, it'll be 5D2/24-105L/35L in my Billingham Hedley Small for travel, and the 85/50/17-40 will live in my Domke/Pelican back in the hotel.

I keep wondering if I'm making excuses for not wanting to pack the "brick" around... but it really does make sense. I agree with keeping a full kit nearby (in the room, the car, etc.), but walking around with a nice prime and a versatile zoom are a great way to go...