The reservation procedure will certainly work, but why not explore your devices to learn which has a fixed IP address, and then change that one to get its IP via DHCP? With every device uses regular DHCP you won't need to make reservations.
From your description, it's probably your Macbook that's got the fixed IP address.
But as JohnDS says, if you have one set to manual and it cannot be changed, then get it outside a range and you'll be good.