I was about to create a thread on this when I saw yours. Apple gets bashed so much that I wanted to complement them.
I really don't care for trackpads, Apple's is MacBook Pro ones are tolerable. I bought the standalone old MT and returned it. I didn't get it. I'm one of those few who love the Magic Mouse. I could rest my hands on the table and just move the mouse. The old trackpad was at an odd angle and you had to hover your fingers over it which caused wrist strain for me. My hand cramped so I returned it. Also, it was kind of small for tracking across large screens (I don't want maximum tracking speed because it's hard to control).
However, I saw the new MT2 in an Apple Store and was astounded at the size and even the appearance. A few minutes of use didn't really show me anything meaningful, but I loved the feedback. For Christmas I actually got one from someone and thought "neat." I tried it and fell in love with it. It's large enough for comparable tracking, the feedback is really nice, and I love the Force-Click for link preview. It's now at much less of an angle and I haven't had any wrist pain. I enjoy tracking with it.
The click feedback is really amazing. I don't mean the sound (which can be disabled, although it's pretty convincing too), but the feel of it. I had to put it on the table and press down while watching just to prove to myself that the surface wasn't actually moving downward with the click. It's been about two months since I've been using mine now, and I'm still amazed by that sensation.
I actually have two comments:
(1) I agree, but have you tried clicking with four fingers? I had a BetterTouchGesture for it and will change it because the feedback is different and it sometimes only clicks once, so it feels like it's stuck, which of course it isn't because it doesn't move. I don't like it.
(2) Do you use the three-finer drag gesture? People say they love it, but I don't really see how it's easier than quickly double tapping with a finger. I wish you could do a 4-fingure drag because I've used 3-fingers for shipping and Mission Control for 3 years and it's hard to unlearn.
🙁