Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

crisss1205

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
I picked up my black Magic Keyboard with Touch ID today. Previously I had the old black full keyboard. Although it is nice to have Touch ID now, I still like the color of the old one which is darker.


20220310_173725.jpg

Old (left)
20220310_173813.jpg

Old (bottom/right)
20220310_174347.jpg
 
I still like the color of the old one which is darker.

Yeah, I prefer the old colour, but I still like the new one.

do have any problem with the black color comes off here and there for your old one?

It does come off, but requires a bit of effort, my mouse kept rubbing against the bottom right corner and it does take the color off.
 
For me the new one is way nicer, the old one was an aesthetic disaster — as are most things in the “space grey” to matte black range. In fact, calling it “new“ is weird, since the aluminum and black combo has been in Apple’s design palette way longer than the horrible space gray
 
  • Like
Reactions: gotong
I have the old black one. I really didn’t want to buy a new keyboard but I have a new 14” MBP M1 Max and wanted to run it in clamshell mode without typing my password all the time. I bought the new black/silver keyboard and think it looks better. I’ll probably clean my old one and sell it.
 
I like the space gray version. I see crazy optical illusions with circular dots appearing and blinking on the silver + black keys it's trippy. 😵 Monochrome Disco all up in here🕺
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Horizon Man
@crisss1205 Are you noting any difference in key travel / overall feel on the new one vs. the old space grey one? I have the same space grey / black key edition and considering the new one, but since I got my 2021 M1 Macbook Pro I dislike the external keyboard the more I use the Macbook Pro keyboard.

Having a space grey Macbook Pro and other accessories in space grey to match, I'm also struggling with the silver color, so if the key travel is not any different, then I may just wait and see if they come out with a space grey edition or improved keys later on.
 
Last edited:
do have any problem with the black color comes off here and there for your old one?

Have had the old Space Gray for almost two years. No sign of any color "coming off". Have been really happy with this keyboard, it's a good match for my 2018 Mini.
 
I just got mine the other day as well and wish it was space grey instead of silver. But it’s very nice and I‘m typing on it now. Has anyone been able to use the TOUCH ID part yet? Is it not possible to use with the iPad Air 4th Gen?
 
The Touch ID is game changer especially if you use Keychain in your browser! The username/password save is game changer in my book!
 
Touch ID is a nice feature to have but I retuned mine because I can't get used to a keyboard that doesn't have back lighting. So I'm keeping my Logi MX Keys until Apple releases a full size keyboard with back lighting.
 
I've been very close to picking one of these up at several points but I'm very worried about the keys shining. That happened on my 13" MBP after only about a year.
 
Same here, I loved the old one, but this one has sharper contrast between the silver and black and I like it too.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.