Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I sold my M1 Mac Mini earlier this week thinking they would announce the "pro" version of the Mac Mini today, man I feel stupid. Now I'm in desperate need of a desktop. I'm considering buying the new MacBook Pro M1 Max and connecting it to an external monitor and just treating it like a desktop, is that stupid to use a laptop as a desktop? I don't need portability. Should I just wait for the new Mac Mini or iMac to come out? I'd be waiting until at least early next year right? I don't know if I can wait that long. I need a powerful computer to edit 8K video files on. Right now these new MacBooks are the most powerful Apple computers available, right?
What you didn't wasn't necessarily stupid. You thought it would be wise to sell it before the new ones were announced, to sell it at higher price. You took a chance and you lost.
While I never owned an Apple laptop, I did used to own (and still do) PC laptops which I mostly used as desktop replacements. All the way back to 2002 when I bought my first laptop after almost 20 years of buying desktop computers. It definitely can work. I wouldn't do it and I don't plan on ever doing it again, but it is definitely doable.
If the Mac Mini with the M1 that is already out was working for you, then you clearly don't NEED the M1 Max laptops. You want them, but you don't need them. We don't know when the new Mac Minis will arrive, it might be this year, it might be next year. If you have work to do that can't wait, then obviously you have to get another machine sooner than later. If I were you and was satisfied with the Mini, I would get it back (or similar) and wait for the new Mini to arrive.
But going for a laptop you don't need, to cover for your mistake* of selling your original Mini, while at the same time you want to get a new (not yet released) Mini, that's making one mistake after another, going for a new record or something.


*Mistake if you need a computer for work. If you have work to do and sell your only tool, then that isn't exactly an Einstein move.
 
I sold my M1 Mac Mini earlier this week thinking they would announce the "pro" version of the Mac Mini today, man I feel stupid. Now I'm in desperate need of a desktop. I'm considering buying the new MacBook Pro M1 Max and connecting it to an external monitor and just treating it like a desktop, is that stupid to use a laptop as a desktop? I don't need portability. Should I just wait for the new Mac Mini or iMac to come out? I'd be waiting until at least early next year right? I don't know if I can wait that long. I need a powerful computer to edit 8K video files on. Right now these new MacBooks are the most powerful Apple computers available, right?
If it were me, I would just cut my losses and buy another M1 Mini. What you are trying to do is pay more for guessing wrong. If you were a laptop person then yeah, buying the new MBP would be a no brainer. You can buy the Mini on Amazon which is on sale again and sell it when the new Mini’s are announced.

I never got the feeling that Apple was going to release a new Mini this year when they released the M1 Mini last year. The Mini’s seem to be on a 2 year cycle so late next year makes more sense.
 
If Apple doesn’t release a desktop with the M1P/M1M SoCs, what is to say they will release one with the M2 along with the new lower end Macbooks?
 
The music industry is still using Rosetta at most or just x86. You would think Logic Pro being vital to Apple that they would have invested resources to accelerate the process. Or, the plan is not as rapid a transition as the fandom rumor sites persist on spreading.
It was Apple that said it was going to be a 2-year transition.
 
  • Love
Reactions: PinkyMacGodess
I never got the feeling that Apple was going to release a new Mini this year when they released the M1 Mini last year. The Mini’s seem to be on a 2 year cycle so late next year makes more sense.
It's too early to say if the Mini is on a 2 year cycle yet but I can see how it might work: The A-series chip bandwagon is an annual update cycle by and large but I would have justified a 2 year cycle by saying that Apple would skip the A15 architecture and use the A16 next year as the basis for what I would logically call an M2 and that would then be used for a refresh of all M1 Macs by October next year.

And going forward the non-Pro CPUs would come from even numbered A series CPUs. It would let Apple show bigger increases between generations and possibly take the heat off.

In the meantime the M1 Pro and M1 Max CPUs seem set to go into the iMac Pro early next year - which would allow Apple to introduce new product on the in-between years - but I can't help thinking that the configuration of the MacBook Pros should be carried over into the iMac Pro - notably 3 Thunderbolt 4 ports plus sundry external ports like additional USB-A, HDMI and perhaps even SD card.

This casts a bit of design shade over the super thin AppleTV Mk1 type design reportedly for the Mini that we've seen from Jon Prosser. There are now 2 question marks over it.

1. Apple are heading into a more form-follows-function period after going too far down the Jony Ive super-thin rabbit hole for a number of years.

2. If we're only having 3 Thunderbolt 4 ports due to the M1 Pro/Max SoC then the CAD design that appears to show 4 unspecified Thunderbolt ports (too close together and in a novel vertical configuration) looks ever more like a trap designed to catch unwary leakers.

I'd say it's unlikely that Apple would fork the low-selling Mac mini to have just M2 and not M1 Pro/Max CPUs in mind.

At a first glance those 4 holes look more convincing as ventilation holes (and no intake?) but then you're left with a situation where there only appears to be 2 main ports - let's be generous and say those USB ports are actually Thunderbolt ports - with the USB-A ports deleted - plus a HDMI.

That ultra-thin sensibility would fit better as a sole successor to the M1 Mini under the old regime but you're going back to a situation where the ultra-thin design has become responsible for a loss of ports from the previous model which seems very unlikely under the direction of travel we've seen from the M1 Pro MacBook Pros. And it's a very niche product to be spending engineering resources to make a new case for, surely?

Portwise, Apple could be going down the road of the iMac 24 where you got 4 USB-C ports - where 2 were Thunderbolt and the other two were USB-C. This would make it easy to make a third one Thunderbolt where the onboard SoC allows (ie M1 Pro or M1 Max) while it might be considered to be more flexible to have a USB-C port instead of an SD port onboard to allow Apple to streamline the parts bin.

Let's clarify more.

Although the thin nature of leak casing is in part explained by having the power supply outside it still seemed strange as a Pro purchase when a large customer is the co-location guys who have designed everything around the existing (now classic) 2018 Mac mini form factor.

Currently the M1 Mini is overspecced for a cooling solution which benefits people who want ultra quiet performance because the fans apparently hardly ever turn on. Brilliant for studio work and for folks who appreciate silence.

So why would Apple then drastically reduce the size of the case, remove ports, and potentially increase the sustained noise/heat in a new Mac mini?

If the pros were being listened to then Apple would have kept the form factor the same and potentially reduce the wifi interference issues by reintroducing more polycarbonate to the design make it more radio transparent. This, however, may impact the recyclability of the case.

However, if we're still using the external iMac power brick it could offer more cooling power to the main case (allowing M1 Pro CPU to feature) but they'd have to find somewhere to stow the brick - images of colo server rooms I have seen don't appear to offer a convenient place to store these things but that's potentially less of a deal breaker than completely re-engineering the case.

Let's forget the leaks for a moment though, I'm sure professionals wanting a headless Mac would take a great deal of interest in a headless 14" MacBook Pro with all ports and options available.

The Colo guys probably wouldn't mind if Apple just delivered it in an existing Mac mini case with no redesign at all - they may not care about wireless interference as they probably turn all that stuff off. The PSU is designed to manage a 65w CPU which covers the M1 Pro/Max SoC and the backside of the mini can accommodate a third Thunderbolt 4 port as it stands while retaining the 2 USB-A ports.

There's even room for the SD card slot too if Apple chose to put one in but as per my suggestion above there's the argument where switching to 4 USB-C ports plus 2 USB-A ports and HDMI gives Apple the ability to streamline the supply chain a bit.

I'd personally suggest that there's no reason why Apple couldn't continue to use the low end M1/M2 in the same case - maybe putting some more work into sorting out the wireless issues as these users are more likely to complain about that. Unless they really are going to use some more radio transparent materials like polycarbonate in the construction while retaining the overall form factor which would be a bonus.

Let's not forget that Apple could easily make a proper Mac Pro in a small Cube style format a compelling upgrade so I could forgive them for not allowing the Mini to get the M1 Max for instance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EntropyQ3
I shutter to think of the base price
Untitled.png
 
Last edited:
$1299 sounds reasonable though for m1pro 512/16
*8-core CPU / 14-core GPU


That’s because you haven’t added the keyboard, trackpad, Apple level screen, webcam, speaker system…
Those things add up.
Well, if you already have such a desktop setup, then you don't need to buy those things again. This would be a direct replacement for my ancient Mac Pro with 30" Cinema Display. Well actually, I'm waiting for a temporary 2014 Mac mini to go there, so technically an Apple Silicon Mac mini would replace that.

However, I haven't decided yet if I'd get a base model M1 Pro or a tarted up M2. If the M1 Pro were only $200 more than say a 512 GB / 16 GB M1 Mac mini, I'd get the M1 Pro. I don't need the extra performance, but the extra ports would be nice. The M1 Pro & M2 would also have ProRes acceleration but I personally don't need that. I suspect the M1 Pro would come out months before the M2 though so that would factor into the decision. If say the M1 Pro Mac mini comes out in the spring, I'd wait until summer and buy it with free AirPods in the summer edu promotion. Truth be told though, I may even consider a base model M2 since this is a secondary machine. Decisions, decisions... Fortunately, we have a lot of time to think about it, since they won't come out until 2022.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: EntropyQ3
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.