New iPad Case Questions

[JoltinJoe]

I recently received a New iPad as a college graduation gift. So grateful. It's beautiful.

I was wondering if anyone had any experience with the Incipio NGP, incase Maki, or Incase Origami sleeves and whether a New iPad with the NGP on would fit inside either the Maki or the Origami.

I realize this is a specific combination, but any feedback on any of these three cases would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

 

[Night Spring]

Incase Origami says it fits all iPads, which would include the first gen, which is thicker than the new iPad in the NGP case. The Maki says it will fit iPad 2 or 3 with Smart Cover, and I doubt the iPad in NGP case is much thicker than an iPad with a Smart Cover. Note, I have used the NGP case, but I haven't used the Maki or Origami, just going by the description on their website.

 

[JoltinJoe]

Incase Origami says it fits all iPads, which would include the first gen, which is thicker than the new iPad in the NGP case. The Maki says it will fit iPad 2 or 3 with Smart Cover, and I doubt the iPad in NGP case is much thicker than an iPad with a Smart Cover. Note, I have used the NGP case, but I haven't used the Maki or Origami, just going by the description on their website.

Thanks for that reasoning, very helpful. How do you like the NGP?

 

[Night Spring]

Thanks for that reasoning, very helpful. How do you like the NGP?

NGP is well-constructed, fits the iPad tightly -- a little too tightly even, as I find that it tends to lift the screen protector I have on my iPad. That's the main reason I'm not using it at the moment. It also has a rubberized, slightly rough texture, which you may or may not like, it's totally personal preference. Personally, I like the smooth TPU ones better, but I would still use the NGP if I could only get it to work with my screen protector.

 

[NikFinn]

I went with the origami over the maki, as it was about $20 cheaper. Very happy with my purchase. When reading reviews I found many people complained about the structural rigidity of the Maki. I haven't had any problems with the origami falling over while typing, which is my main use for it.
Let me know if you have any more questions.

 

[JoltinJoe]

Many thanks to you both. I ordered both the NGP and the Origami. Really excited! I'll update this when they arrive.