Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Only one close to being ok is 6. The rest would cause me to NOT buy the new iPhone.
As far as OP calling the 4/4s a "brick" you must not know what a brick is. IMHO the 4/4s design is the best design on the market. Glass and stainless is > glass and plastic.
 
Only one close to being ok is 6. The rest would cause me to NOT buy the new iPhone.
As far as OP calling the 4/4s a "brick" you must not know what a brick is. IMHO the 4/4s design is the best design on the market. Glass and stainless is > glass and plastic.

Aesthetically speaking I agree. It's a beauty. But in terms of form and function, the iPhone is incredibly uncomfortable to hold or type on for a long period of time. the ergonomics are flat out terrible--pun intended.
 
Aesthetically speaking I agree. It's a beauty. But in terms of form and function, the iPhone is incredibly uncomfortable to hold or type on for a long period of time. the ergonomics are flat out terrible--pun intended.

Yep. It's heavy, it's shaped odd and it feels weird in hand compared to many other phones. People who like the design and feel of the current iPhone probably haven't held something sleek like the Nexus S or the Galaxy S2? I'd gladly welcome a new design that's sure to be coming.
 
Yep. It's heavy, it's shaped odd and it feels weird in hand compared to many other phones. People who like the design and feel of the current iPhone probably haven't held something sleek like the Nexus S or the Galaxy S2? I'd gladly welcome a new design that's sure to be coming.


Former NS owner. That thing was perfect to hold. Not many did, but I for one loved the back "lip" at the bottom too. Gave you a great way to grasp the phone and to pull it out of pocket.
 
a lot of these designs had sharp corners which I would hate. All the iPhones so far have had rounded edges which I think they will keep doing and for good reason.

I did like a couple of those designs though. I am not opposed to a curved back, especially if I can set the phone down without the camera touching the surface.

I love the idea for a home button that doubles as light notifications.
 
Wirelessly posted

As much as I like the majority of those concepts im worried apple isn't going to change the design. Remember, Apple doesn't just do things to do things. The iPhone is slaughtering the way it is. All you have to do is look at their current product line. If their is a change it's subtle and purposeful and not done for no reason.
 
Only one close to being ok is 6. The rest would cause me to NOT buy the new iPhone.
As far as OP calling the 4/4s a "brick" you must not know what a brick is. IMHO the 4/4s design is the best design on the market. Glass and stainless is > glass and plastic.

A brick has 6 flat sides. The iPhone 4/4s also features 6 flat sides.

Calling something the "best design on the market" is subjective. Still so many people having a problem separating opinion from fact. Fact is, there is no "best design on the market". Want to throw in a "in my opinion", then sure..go for it. Everyone has different tastes, likes, needs and wants. No single "best" design/size.

The phone shown on 1-4 looks like an updated, more bulbous Pre. 11 does look good...other than the flat sides...but also looks like an HTC clone. 9 is pretty nice, with removing the physical home button. Several poorly doen Nokia clones and bunch of hot garbage. I don't want my phone to have a striking design, I want it to be comfortable to hold and use.

----------

a lot of these designs had sharp corners which I would hate. All the iPhones so far have had rounded edges which I think they will keep doing and for good reason.

I did like a couple of those designs though. I am not opposed to a curved back, especially if I can set the phone down without the camera touching the surface.

I love the idea for a home button that doubles as light notifications.

Uhhhh....the edges on the 4/4S are not rounded. Yes, the band/antenna around the outside makes it less sharp than some of the concepts there, but still not rounded at all.
 
The problem with this sort of thing is that people who are good at 3D computer design seem to have very different skills than the people who are good at real-world design.

I'd love to get some jewelry makers, watch makers, and car radio designers into a room and have THEM work out some concepts. That would be cool.

But as it is, having 3D artists work out these things is like asking a baker to cook a steak. Their fields are close...but not quite the same thing. Which leads to stuff like that link.
 
The problem with this sort of thing is that people who are good at 3D computer design seem to have very different skills than the people who are good at real-world design.

I'd love to get some jewelry makers, watch makers, and car radio designers into a room and have THEM work out some concepts. That would be cool.

But as it is, having 3D artists work out these things is like asking a baker to cook a steak. Their fields are close...but not quite the same thing. Which leads to stuff like that link.

Exactly. The mockups themselves aren't bad for the most part, it's the actual phone they are depicting which is no good.
 
Wirelessly posted

I don't have a problem with thicker. I really liked the lumia inspired big screen thick concept. Apple could put a big ass battery in there for beastly battery life.
 
.....IMHO the 4/4s design is the best design on the market. Glass and stainless is > glass and plastic.

....
Calling something the "best design on the market" is subjective. Still so many people having a problem separating opinion from fact. Fact is, there is no "best design on the market". Want to throw in a "in my opinion" then sure..go for it. Everyone has different tastes, likes, needs and wants. No single "best" design/size.

IMHO means in my honest opinion. Just a heads up.

I don't have a problem with thicker. I really liked the lumia inspired big screen thick concept. Apple could put a big ass battery in there for beastly battery life.
I wouldn't mind either but could you imagine if it is thicker? You would be able to surf the poor fanboi's tears as they flowed like uncheck rivers! Look at the major cry baby sessions that occured when the iPad was made thicker! You'd of thought the late SJ's ghost snuck into their rooms and had his way with them the way some of them reacted.
The unrealstic fb's think it's possible to make a phone paper thin while having 4 days of useage and 5 days of standby. Of course if early rumors do say it's thicker the posts would start...."Steve would never have let it be thicker", "No way it's going to be thicker, that's so un-apple", ect ect. I'll just sit back and laugh muhhahahahahahahahahah
 
Last edited:
So glad Jony Ive is still the one designing the iPhone, and not any of these concept artists!
 
Aesthetically speaking I agree. It's a beauty. But in terms of form and function, the iPhone is incredibly uncomfortable to hold or type on for a long period of time. the ergonomics are flat out terrible--pun intended.

Very True, but I got an Otterbox Defender case for mine. It adds some bulk to the phone and takes away some of the beauty, however it makes it much more comfortable to hold (and practically invincible).
 
I personally like the iPhone 4 design and don't feel it needs changed. I need a little bit of a bezel for holding without touching the screen.
 
#10 looks amazing.

Some of them are atrocious though. A few of them looked exactly like Sony Ericssons from 2008. Say goodbye to Apple if they ever release anything that ugly.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.