New Keyboard Design For MB Pro

[Velin]

A single question: when?

 

[leman]

A simple answer: nobody knows.

 

[sennomulo]

A simple answer: nobody knows.

Well, some people know. But they're not going to tell us.

 

[leman]

Well, some people know. But they're not going to tell us.

Thats the point 🙂

 

[Velin]

I’m asking this again. When will we have a new MacBook Pro with a good keyboard? Needing a 15 inch Pro, want it new, but can’t stand butterfly BS.

 

[MrUNIMOG]

I’m asking this again. When will we have a new MacBook Pro with a good keyboard? Needing a 15 inch Pro, want it new, but can’t stand butterfly BS.

"Butterfly" isn't synonymous to "unreliable".
Heck, it doesn't even necessarily mean low key travel, which some people seem to dislike.

I've yet to see data to suggests the 2019 iteration is any less reliable than previous "Scissor" keyboards.

Should Apple actually decide to go back to a scissor-type mechanism for whatever reason (PR would be one), that won't magically give you better reliability. And if you expect increased key travel, prepare for disappointment.

 

[Velin]

"Butterfly" isn't synonymous to "unreliable".

The butterfly keyboard replacement and extended warranty programs indicate otherwise.

 

[MrUNIMOG]

The butterfly keyboard replacement and extended warranty programs indicate otherwise.

I'm willing to believe the 2016 iteration of the "butterfly" keyboard may have had significantly higher failure rates than previous "scissor" keyboards, although mine's been fine.

However I strongly doubt Apple would continue selling millions of Mac notebooks with catastrophic keyboard failure rates. That's quite a lot of free top case replacements..

Post-2016 models being included in the warranty program seems more like a PR move than anything else.

 

[Howard2k]

I’m asking this again. When will we have a new MacBook Pro with a good keyboard? Needing a 15 inch Pro, want it new, but can’t stand butterfly BS.

Nobody here can give you a firm answer on that.

The rumoured 16" apparently may have a new keyboard mechanism. It could be assumed that if the 16" doe appear, and if it has a new keyboard, then we'll get a new 15" with new keyboard at some point too. But there are no firm details, nothing but speculation.

May as well ask your magic 8 ball.