Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Which Macbook Pro is the best? and WHY?


  • Total voters
    46

riz78612

macrumors regular
Original poster
Dec 29, 2007
119
0
http://www.anandtech.com/mac/showdoc.aspx?i=3431


Starting with the MacBook Pro: Smaller, Bigger, Lower Power and Lower Battery Life?
Ok now this is kind of sneaky, Apple made the MacBook Pro thinner than any other MacBook Pro, but it's wider, deeper and heavier. Granted, these are minor increases in dimensions, total volume actually decreased by about a percent. The 0.1 lbs increase in weight is most likely due to the use of glass on both the display and trackpad.

But for so much glass only a 0.1 lbs increase in weight isn't bad, oh but wait, the battery went from a 60WHr unit to a 50WHr unit. A lighter battery to offset weight gains elsewhere.

The give and take continues when you look at the hardware specs. Apple did a lot to reduce power consumption on the MacBook Pro: the GeForce 9400M chipset will use less power than Intel's G35M which was used on the previous notebook, DDR3 runs at a lower voltage than DDR2 (1.5V vs. 1.8V) and thus we see a drop in power there as well. However the reduction in total system power needs is offset by the fact that the new MacBook Pro has a smaller battery, so I'd expect battery life to stay roughly the same.

Granted the MacBook Pro was never a slouch when it came to battery life, I measured a worst case of 3.38 hours on the MacBook Pro and a best case of over 5.1 hours - just don't expect any better from the new one.
 
2008 Penryn FTW...new macbook pros suck :S
They are like Macbooks,but with a couple extra features...not cool apple, not cool.
Bring back the PRO part of the macbook pro!
 
If you like the design, the new keyboard and don't mind a glossy screen, then get the new one.

Otherwise if you absolutely hate everything about the new design, then go with the Penryn MBP.
 
If you like the design, the new keyboard and don't mind a glossy screen, then get the new one.

Exactly. This was "the update I was waiting for", as I've had to drag my PowerBook G4 12" kicking and screaming into each new year.
To me, the spec increases as far as CPU, GPU, and HD accessibility go, it's worth it to me.

And of course, no offense to anyone else, but is this not what it all comes down to... who cares about what works for anyone else, use what works for you. ;)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.