New MBA with external monitor or iMac.

[Stanwf]

I have a new 11 in MBA (8gb) and will buy either an external monitor or an iMac for Aperture use. I don't need two computers but is there any big advantage with an iMac?

 

[Eddy Munn]

I have a new 11 in MBA (8gb) and will buy either an external monitor or an iMac for Aperture use. I don't need two computers but is there any big advantage with an iMac?

The advantage is that it's a computer, not just a screen.
You could always source a different monitor too, other than Apples selection.

 

[Santabean2000]

I have a new 11 in MBA (8gb) and will buy either an external monitor or an iMac for Aperture use. I don't need two computers but is there any big advantage with an iMac?

We need to know more about your situation. How big is your library? Might you need external hdds? Why have you bought an ultaportable MBA?

I'd consider a Thunderbolt Display with a FW or TB external attached, if it's just for home use. [I'm expecting TB Displays to be upgraded along side the new MPs on the 22nd.]

 

[Abazigal]

I have a new 11 in MBA (8gb) and will buy either an external monitor or an iMac for Aperture use. I don't need two computers but is there any big advantage with an iMac?

The imac would have better specs for more intensive computing stuff.

Personally, since you already have the air, and if Aperture runs smoothly enough on the air, I would just recommend you get an external display.

 

[KeegM480]

I would suggest a MacBook Pro even if you have to get a slightly used one but if that's not an option then get a 13" Air, you will probably end up wanting the portability just make sure to get decent specs

 

[mattbaar26]

Get an external monitor, you will save at least $400 even if you get an ultra high end monitor.

 

[glenthompson]

I use an external monitor with my 15" MBP. Prefer it over an iMac since it gives me portability. I've been using a laptop as my primary machine for over 20 years and like the flexibility. If the Air meets your current needs, keep it and get a good monitor.

 

[Stanwf]

Thanks everyone, I was inclined to go the monitor route and now even more so.

 

[old-wiz]

I'd go for a good quality external monitor. I have a 2008 24" iMac, but when it dies I'll get a high end Mac Mini and a good display. I hate having to toss out a great display just because the internals get fried.