These now sound like fun hacks to get iMessage working on an Android, not a paid product from a legit company.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Next Beeper Mini Fix Requires Users to Have a Mac
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
This is ridiculous, what is the point of this app if you need to be part of the Apple eco-system to begin with? Next, the app developer will say that you will need an iOS device...
This app was doomed from the start and it is slowly heading down towards irrelevancy....
This app was doomed from the start and it is slowly heading down towards irrelevancy....
Just turn off iMessage in the Message app, it will work just like any sms/mms messaging app on any phone before smart phones were a thing. Many android phones only have one SMS messaging app.
If I wanted to use iMessage bad enough that I'd use/buy a Mac to relay I think I'd just buy an iPhone and be done
Good lord, just give it up. This has gotten pathetic now.
That seems like a reasonable option seeing how you can change your default email/web browser. Not that I would switch to anything else for my messages
If you're desperate enough to jump through all these hoops for iMessage, just buy a damn iPhone.
You can remove iMessage from your homescreen if you want and can use What’sApp instead.
Then I can't receive sms.
I like iMessage, it just doesn't work for my situation.
Given that iPhone vastly outsells the Mac, the number of people with a Mac but without an iPhone is surely near zero.
Sorry, I corrected myself. You can remove it from your Home Screen, but you can’t delete it entirely. Likely because of SMS.
How is it anti-competitive?
- Apple is not blocking messages. SMS still works.
- The iMessage service is not a public service. Apple built it and owns it.
- Apple has not given Bleeper Mini authorized access to the service. They "broke in".
iMessage is an internet-based messaging channel, owned by Apple. There are MANY of these available — for free — to consumers. Plenty of choice in the marketplace.
So, try again?
Oh yeah they seem to be listening don’t they.
You don’t have to like every aspect of the products but you also can’t expect to change them for a small percentage of customers needs.
Apple has agreed to support RCS starting in 2024. That will bring many of the same iMessage-like features to Android. Rich messages, larger attachments and media. Requires a data connection, same as iMessage. SMS remains the fallback in the event of no data connection.
Not sure why Beeper Mini is so desperate. In a few months, their app will be completely irrelevant.
What is your dilemma? That people text you and you're not receiving "rich" messages from Android users on your iPhone? You admit to having an Android phone. Where does it fit into your day-to-day life? Do you carry it with you everywhere? If you are receiving SMS messages from Android users, and you want to receive "rich" messages from them, just give them your Android number. Problem solved.
big difference
Apple could have came up with the same implementation on their own. Beeper on the other hand is riding on Apple's services.
I use imessage just for SMS, that's it. I don't even use imessage other than receiving SMS. Just use whatsapp/signal for texting need. It's just way more advance and feature rich.
Apple has done all they "need" to do - enable RCS next year for a more secure and better overall "normal" texting experience. They're never going to give up the blue bubble / iMessage stranglehold, and I don't blame them. It makes zero business sense right now.
Nah this‘ll be the slow decline of their app. Most people already annoyed by the fact that this service is very unreliable and they need to set up stuff every two days.
My bet is they will slowly back out and shut it down in the near future. Reap what you sow, they had a thing there with their Beeper Cloud service (which Apple ignored) but they poked the bee hive and have to now face the full wrath of Apple, losing even that silver lining.
This never really made sense to begin with RCS on the horizon… looked immediately like a cheap cash grab bait monetizing an essentially open sourced reverse engineering knowledge.
Apple needs to slap Beeper around a lot harder.
iMessage isn’t SMS
The Messages app is not iMessage.
You can disable iMessage and never use it. The Messages app existed before iMessage existed. It will just use SMS/MMS and soon RCS. Plenty of people never use iMessage on their devices. They can even use the same Messages app on iPad and Mac without iMessage to receive SMS/MMS (and soon RCS).
iMessage is an over-the-top, web-based messaging service that is entirely optional to use.
Which are of zero use when communicating with iOS users who refuse to leave the Apple Messages app. Much of this isn't really about Android users loving iMessage specifically, its about Android users wanting to be able to use modern, rich communication features when communicating with iPhone users who won't use other chat apps.
iMessage integration is only one part of their service. In addition to Beeper Mini (which focuses on iMessage) they have another app (Beeper Cloud) which is a multi-network chat app. Even if the iMessage integration goes away, they've generated a lot of brand awareness recently which will probably be of benefit to them.
Last edited: