It didn’t feel “fiddly:”
- I hooked antenna into the standard cable jack that would be required on this hypothetical AppleTV.
- I hooked one ethernet cable into the same switch to which the ethernet cable from my AppleTV connects.
- Then I plugged it in so it would be powered.
- Done.
So the unique fiddling vs. the concept is either #3 (one more thing to plug in)… and maybe #2 for those who lean on wifi for AppleTV. In exchange for #2 + #3, I get
two 4K tuners and
two HDTV tuners instead of just one… and it slings video to up to
ALL Apple technology in my home instead of only
one box hooked to only
one TV.
Whether an Apple app or Channels app, an app will be required to display channels, so I consider that “the same” effort to get it functionally working.
The bigger point is that you can have what you want now or you can leave it a wish that Apple probably never fulfills. Why? Because they would rather profit from renting/selling/subscriptions of the same content. Modern Apple has little interest in free, only in how they can get their 30% for other people’s creations.
If you actually want this on AppleTV, get it by the way it
already works (and has for some time now). Else, I’ll wish for a deluxe AppleTV right with you just to keep Apple developing “the hobby.” I very likely wouldn’t buy it unless it was the
only option and I needed another AppleTV.
As to all that earlier stuff, yes, my locals are jamming simulcast HD signals into ATSC 3, H.265 streams. But Apple adding a 4K tuner to AppleTV (or that Zapperbox and similar) wouldn’t have any effect on that either. Should any local broadcaster opt to start broadcasting 4K, this box is ready to receive those signals now... and existing AppleTVs and a prior generation AppleTV 4K is ready to display them.
And a correction: HDHomeRun is just "passing through" whatever signal is being broadcast by the local stations, not upscaling as you imagine. AppleTV or iDevices or Mac simply get whatever the broadcasters are offering. There's no new processing of the signal. It's actually the AppleTV itself that is doing the upscaling when hooked to a 4K television. If a local broadcaster(s) would transmit anything in 4K, this box will receive it in 4K, pass it to AppleTV (or iDevices or Macs) in 4K to be displayed at 4K on a 4K television or scaled for the iDevice or Mac screen.
Lastly: here's the same reviewer talking up this option from when it launched a few years ago...
...and here's a
very obvious (first few seconds) Apple guy talking this 4K tuner box up more recently...
He seems to illustrate the playback option of using Silicon Dusts own app on his screen, but Channels and PLEX (apps) can work with HDHomeRuns too, as can some other hardware. Even TVs with "old" DLNA technology will recognize the boxes on the network and be able to play anything they receive directly.