Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

No right click in XP - 17 Macbook Pro

I

Igotmacqs

macrumors member
Original poster
Mar 10, 2009
41
0
I have a new 17 MBP and love it so far with some small probs. Under Boot Camp running XP, there is no right click (alt click is a no-go as well) on the touchpad. Right click works fine on the mouse and under Mac OS, but...

Anyone else?
 
I am also Boot Camping XP.
In order to right-click in XP, you should have two fingers planted on the track pad, then click with a third finger.
I don't remember how I figured that out... but it works.

If anyone knows a simple way to right-click in XP, please post it here.
In OS X I'm simply using the lower-right corner of the trackpad to right-click.
 
Igotmacqs said:
I have a new 17 MBP and love it so far with some small probs. Under Boot Camp running XP, there is no right click (alt click is a no-go as well) on the touchpad. Right click works fine on the mouse and under Mac OS, but...

Anyone else?
Click to expand...

Did you install the drivers from the bootcamp cd?
 
Hah, it's a weird thing. In Boot Camp preference pane in Control Panel, it clearly says two-fingers but in order to get secondary clicking, three fingers is needed, hah. There is no fix that I'm aware of and updating the Boot Camp drivers 2.1 or if you're installing using the unibody install disc doesn't help the problem I find.
 
In order to right-click in XP, you should have two fingers planted on the track pad, then click with a third finger.
Click to expand...

Wow, thanks. That is almost unusable, huh? I am unintendedly scrolling and losing the options, etc.

Yes, I have installed the bootcamp drivers. The trackpad fix that was supposed to correct this will not install on the new 17. If you go to Apple updates, it will find the update for the track pad, and will act like it has installed it, but try again after reboot, and the update is still there.

I have spent almost 3 hours with tech support on the phone, and they have supposedly communicated this to engineering, but as of yet, no fix.

Thanks for letting me know it is not just me:D
 
iLog.Genius said:
I don't think it's a big deal, instead of 2 fingers, you have to use 3.
Click to expand...

Is that sarcasm?

It is a big deal, you're not suppose to change how people use their fingers on macs and pcs. Muscle memory is an important factor to consider.
 
MikhailT said:
Is that sarcasm?

It is a big deal, you're not suppose to change how people use their fingers on macs and pcs. Muscle memory is an important factor to consider.
Click to expand...

Nope, if you feel it's a problem that's fine, state the complaint. I don't see how using a third finger to scroll or right-click something is a problem since I'm already using the 3 and 4 finger gestures in OS X anyway so it's an easy adjustment for me and I'm just speaking for myself.
 
iLog.Genius said:
I don't think it's a big deal, instead of 2 fingers, you have to use 3.
Click to expand...

The big deal is that you have to keep two fingers perfectly still while clicking the button with a third finger. If you move either of your fingers the tiniest bit, either the mouse will move (possibly off of the object you're trying to click on), or the window will scroll. And the scroll implementation is so fast and jumpy it's almost completely unusable.

It's widely known that Apple's trackpad drivers for Windows are complete garbage. I always use Fusion or plug in an external mouse when using boot camp.
 
Runt888 said:
The big deal is that you have to keep two fingers perfectly still while clicking the button with a third finger. If you move either of your fingers the tiniest bit, either the mouse will move (possibly off of the object you're trying to click on), or the window will scroll. And the scroll implementation is so fast and jumpy it's almost completely unusable.

It's widely known that Apple's trackpad drivers for Windows are complete garbage. I always use Fusion or plug in an external mouse when using boot camp.
Click to expand...

Wow maybe I'm just use to it. Secondary clicking in Windows is the exact same way as secondary clicking in OS X but instead of 2 you're trapping the trackpad with 3 fingers at once. Guess it's personal preference, learned and used to the gestures in OS X, I just translate or move over to XP.
 
iLog.Genius said:
Wow maybe I'm just use to it. Secondary clicking in Windows is the exact same way as secondary clicking in OS X but instead of 2 you're trapping the trackpad with 3 fingers at once. Guess it's personal preference, learned and used to the gestures in OS X, I just translate or move over to XP.
Click to expand...

Are you using the new 17?
 
iLog.Genius said:
No, Late-2008 15". Something different in the 17" that's not in 15"?:confused:
Click to expand...

Yes (well, at least supposedly yes, according to Apple tech support). The 17 will not accept the patch that fixes some odd Windows trackpad behaviors. I agree with you that a 3 finger tap would be no problem, but in some instances, it is very buggy seeming. For example: a 3 finger click on the desktop works perfectly, but a 3 finger click on selected text is about a 1 in 3 venture. Not a technique issue, I promise.

A lower right click option would be so nice, but enabling the patch for this new machine would probably suffice.
 
MikhailT said:
Is that sarcasm?

It is a big deal, you're not suppose to change how people use their fingers on macs and pcs. Muscle memory is an important factor to consider.
Click to expand...

Wow you must really have a hard time in life. I have no problem at all using 3 fingers to right click in Windows XP on my MPB. Any windows mouse or even the Mac mouse works. But again I dont have any issues.
 
No right click in XP - 17 Macbook Pro

thats the 1 thing i hate about using WXP on My Mac. I Never Figured out how to riight click. but now i know. Hah
 
iLog.Genius said:
Are you referring to:

http://www.apple.com/downloads/maco.../macbookmacbookprotrackpadfirmwareupdate.html

OR

http://www.apple.com/downloads/maco.../multitouchtrackpadupdateforwindowsvista.html

What error message are you getting? I believe the top one should already be installed (user doesn't have to do it) and the second one I think doesn't apply if you installed Boot Camp 2.1 drivers which should already come on your OS X install disk. Not 100% sure but I'm going to look into it.
Click to expand...

A manual install of the bottom (Windows) patch fails. The error message reads that it is not intended for this computer.

Apple software update (in windows) finds the same patch and acts like it is intalling it, asks for a reboot, and makes no note of installation failure. But, running Apple software update again after reboot finds the same patch. Apple needs to update the patch to allow installation on the new 17.

I have no problem at all using 3 fingers to right click in Windows XP on my MPB.
Click to expand...

I would guess it is a older model or a 15. This is not user error. It is a bug (one that will drive you to near madness if you have 8 hours on a plane and 100 Outlook email to get through).
 
Igotmacqs said:
A manual install of the bottom (Windows) patch fails. The error message reads that it is not intended for this computer.

Apple software update (in windows) finds the same patch and acts like it is intalling it, asks for a reboot, and makes no note of installation failure. But, running Apple software update again after reboot finds the same patch. Apple needs to update the patch to allow installation on the new 17.



I would guess it is a older model or a 15. This is not user error. It is a bug (one that will drive you to near madness if you have 8 hours on a plane and 100 Outlook email to get through).
Click to expand...

I can see how frustration can set especially since Apple mouse/keyboard isn't really optimized for Windows. If you're in Windows, suggest you find the keyboard shortcuts - as I find to be much easier than using the trackpad.
(ex. to delete, fn+delete button rather than right clicking and selecting delete)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back