Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

kwong2006

macrumors regular
Original poster
May 16, 2006
209
0
My Apple earphone finally kicked the bucket (after a few months :mad: ), and I am looking for a replacement.

I looked at some products from Altec Lansing, but then I discovered some active noise-canceling in-ear earphones. They are either made by Sony or Audio-Technica.

Are they worth it? I've been getting mixed messages with that.
 
noise canceling ( active ) really only work for repetitive low pitched sounds ( like if you were standing next to a helicopter, in a train, etc)
most of them require a battery, are bulky, and really are not worth the price in my opinion

Just get some quality in ear headphones. many of the good ones include foam ear tips that work just like earplugs and drone out most of the ambient sound anyways.
 
Noise-canceling earbuds always seemed like a waste of money, to me. Usually, they act more like earplugs than anything else, and often don't deliver enough of a sound difference than less-expensive models to justify the price difference.
 
I prefer IEM's or just regular closed headphones.

Me said:
More importantly IEMs accomplish two tasks at once. First, they isolate use from the noise. They don’t actively cancel the noise out like Bose has been so famous for doing, rather they passively prevent the sound from ever reaching your ears. Bose and other noise-cancelling headphones have a microphone built into the unit itself, it picks up the sound around you and then recognizes the sounds and produces sound waves that will cancel out the ones around you. IEMs rely on simply creating a tight seal with the inner part of your ear, not allowing it to ever come in. Shure even includes a foam tip that resembles what a standard ear plug looks like, as they function in identical ways. Secondly, IEM’s produce extremely good sound quality, not only do the drivers (mini-speakers, things that produce the sound) that come in IEMs tend to be much better then your standard Apple headphones, but because the tight seal with your ear has occurred, the sound goes straight to your ear, rather then bouncing around and escaping through cracks in between your ear and the headphone. They also produce pure sound as opposed to what comes from active noise-cancelling headphones which has been tainted by the additional waves used to cancel the noise. There are also two other significant benefits over active noise-cancelling headphones: first is that they require no additional battery and secondly that they are much smaller, similar to your standard Apple headphones

I recently spoke with Matt Engstrom, the Category Manager of Monitoring Products for Shure. I asked him the same question I answered above about why one should prefer Shure over Bose (IEMs vs Noise-Cancelling), he gave a different response. Most importantly: sound is all subjective.
Matt Engstrom said:
Well first and foremost isn’t it great that we live in a day of age where people have these great choices. Form-factor, our earphones break down to a very small little carrying pouch that fits in a briefcase very easily. Even the most compact of noise-cancellation headphones have a much larger carrying case. When it comes to sound quality, everything is subjective; but, the facts are noise-cancelation: requires a battery, it induces artifacts into music, many people won’t hear those artifacts, so it’s probably not a factor for a lot of folks. But purists, anyone who is really concerned with the accuracy of their signal, would probably never chose anything with an active circuitry geared towards cancellation and that’s the market that we really cater to. To spend more, you are getting a much smaller form factor, hopefully a much superior audio quality, I cannot really speak to the build quality as a real reason, but with any Shure product you are going to be backed by a pretty robust warranty period and a great service experience if there are any problems.

I use Shure SE530s.
 
A +1 for In Ear Monitors

I use Westone 3 and have previously had Westone UM2. I think they are fantastic.

I have previously had Shure models. These were very good and their warranty cover was excellent, they replaced a damaged pair with a brand new set.

I keep my Westone 3 set in a soft pouch in my jeans pocket. Try doing that with Bose noise cancelling models (which I also have a pair of).
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.