Noise Cancelling Headphones...

edge540

macrumors regular
Original poster
May 10, 2004
213
0
Indiana
I want to get some noise cancelling headphones, but not the big heavy ones like the bose quiet confort. What are the best in ear noise, cancelling headphones?
Thanks,
 

diehldun

macrumors 6502a
Nov 15, 2003
674
0
edge540 said:
I want to get some noise cancelling headphones, but not the big heavy ones like the bose quiet confort. What are the best in ear noise, cancelling headphones?
Thanks,
bose
 

Mechcozmo

macrumors 603
Jul 17, 2004
5,215
2
I have the Bose Quiet Comfort 2 headphones. They are the best. They are light, do a great job, and I love them. I took them on an airplane and at first was surprised that they didn't block as much sound as I thought. Then I took them off to move around and it was loud!

Plus they come with adaptors for just about anything. :)
 

rwk001

macrumors member
Nov 21, 2004
30
0
Bose QuietComfort 2

Very comfortable, work as advertised, particularly on airplanes. But be aware that as part of the noise cancelling process, the headphones generate a sound pressure that pushes against the eardrum, which for me caused a headache. For most people, it's not an issue, but I was bothered by the pressure and eventually ebayed them.
 

puckhead193

macrumors G3
May 25, 2004
9,210
432
NY
I have to agree Bose, I have the first seires and they are amazing, my brother has the second series and i loved them even more then i love mine, infact i'm thinking of upgrading
 

comictimes

macrumors 6502a
Jun 20, 2004
874
1
Berkeley, California
umm... yeah. He specificallly said not bose, because they are so big.

For smaller headphones, I would go with the Shure E3c. They aren't technically noise cancelling (they don't need batteries or anything), but they are noise isolating headphones, so they're designed to make a really good seal with your ear, so noise doesn't get in. If you're on a budget, you could get the E2c headphones. My mom has a pair, and they have very good sound isolation, and quite good sound quality. It's just that the sound quality of the E3c's is even better.
 

Zeke

macrumors 6502a
Oct 5, 2002
507
1
Greenville, SC
I was actually very impressed with Sony's MDR-NC11 (actually the model before this but these are the ones I could find the part number on and I'm sure they're the same). I thought they worked much better than the Bose personally. With these someone talking was basically canceled out where with the Bose you can pretty easily hear someone talk. They only canceled out low frequency.
 

Diatribe

macrumors 601
Jan 8, 2004
4,226
21
Back in the motherland
Get the Etymotic ER-6 or ER-6i (or the ER-4 if you have enough money). They are the best in noise cancelling there is because they are in-ear headphones, plus they sound awesome.
With the ER-6i and the ER-4 you cannot hear the airplane noise while flying, very nice and quiet.
Etymotic Research
 

lasuther

macrumors 6502a
Feb 13, 2004
670
0
Grand Haven, Michigan
Diatribe said:
Get the Etymotic ER-6 or ER-6i (or the ER-4 if you have enough money). They are the best in noise cancelling there is because they are in-ear headphones, plus they sound awesome.
With the ER-6i and the ER-4 you cannot hear the airplane noise while flying, very nice and quiet.
Etymotic Research

What he said. I have both ER6 and ER4 Etymotics and they are great. I've heard good things about Shure E3c.

lasuther
 

wPod

macrumors 68000
Aug 19, 2003
1,654
0
Denver, CO
bose.

i know you said not bose, but they work better than anything else out there. the small in ear ones are the worst. i tried a pair of sony in-ear and they are horrible compared to the bose. other full size earphones are good, but still not the quality of bose.
 

Diatribe

macrumors 601
Jan 8, 2004
4,226
21
Back in the motherland
wPod said:
bose.

i know you said not bose, but they work better than anything else out there. the small in ear ones are the worst. i tried a pair of sony in-ear and they are horrible compared to the bose.
Better than anything else out there huh?
You must have had a lot of time and money trying out every single one...

THE small in ear ones are the worst?
You come to that conclusion by having tested ONE pair?

I'm sorry if this sounds harsh but if you have nothing to say don't post.
 

Spymit007

macrumors regular
Aug 25, 2004
119
0
Massachusetts
Diatribe said:
Better than anything else out there huh?
You must have had a lot of time and money trying out every single one...

THE small in ear ones are the worst?
You come to that conclusion by having tested ONE pair?

I'm sorry if this sounds harsh but if you have nothing to say don't post.
Jeez, did someone wake up on the wrong side of the bed this morning? That wasn't harsh, that was downright nasty. People need to chill out.

Anyway, my vote would go for Bose as well. While I haven't test EVERY pair as Diatribe seems to think one should do before making an informed opinion, I have gone through many in my lifetime and thus far, I conclude that my Bose headphones have given me the most enjoyment so far.

As for the in ear headphones, I like them. I have a $50 Sony pair which I use when I work out. It works excellent. I couldn't bear to use my Bose ones while I work out and have sweat drip on them. I know that Sony sells a much more expensive $100+ in ear noise cancelling headphones and although I haven't had the opportunity to use them, I wouldn't think they'd be dramatically different from my $50 pair. The fact that they are in ear would mean by default that a lot of outside background noise would be blocked out but that's just my own logic...free of any bitter or resentful retorts...
 

Ipaqman

macrumors 6502
Sep 22, 2003
338
0
i just ordered the e3C's, and should recieve them tomorrow. after hours of research on the ety 6i's and the shure e3C's i took the shures over the ety's. i would say go with the shure's, but that's just my opinion.
ipaqman
 

Diatribe

macrumors 601
Jan 8, 2004
4,226
21
Back in the motherland
Spymit007 said:
Jeez, did someone wake up on the wrong side of the bed this morning? That wasn't harsh, that was downright nasty. People need to chill out.

Anyway, my vote would go for Bose as well. While I haven't test EVERY pair as Diatribe seems to think one should do before making an informed opinion, I have gone through many in my lifetime and thus far, I conclude that my Bose headphones have given me the most enjoyment so far.
Nasty? Someone is overly sensitive here. ;)
My point was that general statements like "this is the best" and "this kind is crap" are crap too. If you think something is good, state why, the same with the things you don't like because this way it seems like one doesn't want to help but rather persuade and state opinion for fact.

And you don't need to have tested every single one but saying that an entire product linne is crap because you have tested a low end product of that line is kind of low.

Sorry if this "offends" again but this is just a pet peeve of mine. No hard feelings. :)
 

devman

macrumors 65816
Apr 19, 2004
1,240
4
AU
What he said

Diatribe said:
Get the Etymotic ER-6 or ER-6i (or the ER-4 if you have enough money). They are the best in noise cancelling there is because they are in-ear headphones, plus they sound awesome.
With the ER-6i and the ER-4 you cannot hear the airplane noise while flying, very nice and quiet.
Etymotic Research
Yep - what he said times 2 :) I've got the ER-4p. Awesome! And, no noise-cancelling circuitry (and therefore - bulk) required.
 
Size matters.

The bigger ones are going to be better because they cover more of your ear to isolate and then cancel the exterior sound. Larger headphones will block more of the outside sound even without the noise-cancelling features. That's why in situations where the noise level is loud enough to cause damage, people have giant ear protectors on instead of little plugs in their canals.
 

Silencio

macrumors 68020
Jul 18, 2002
2,357
228
NYC
The Sennheiser PXC-250 is well worth a look. They're not in-ear, but more like compact over-the-ear headphones. Despite the fact that they don't sit in the ear canal like earbuds or completely cover your ears like the Bose, the noise cancelling circuitry is very effective - especially on airplanes.
 

utah_boy2

macrumors regular
Apr 29, 2003
108
0
Middle of Utah
I got the Etymotic ER4s and I think they are kind of painfull to use all day. I went back to the stock earbuds after trying them for a month.

Make sure you are ok with the in-ear type before spending too much on them.
 

ieani

macrumors 6502a
Jan 3, 2006
827
0
the states for now
wPod said:
bose.

i know you said not bose, but they work better than anything else out there. the small in ear ones are the worst. i tried a pair of sony in-ear and they are horrible compared to the bose. other full size earphones are good, but still not the quality of bose.
That is because sony makes some of the worst headphones you can buy.

Diatribe said:
Get the Etymotic ER-6 or ER-6i (or the ER-4 if you have enough money). They are the best in noise cancelling there is because they are in-ear headphones, plus they sound awesome.
With the ER-6i and the ER-4 you cannot hear the airplane noise while flying, very nice and quiet.
Etymotic Research
The Shure E3c's are far more durable though.
 

Yoyodyne

macrumors member
Jul 30, 2005
69
0
Uqbar
ieani said:
That is because sony makes some of the worst headphones you can buy.



The Shure E3c's are far more durable though.
Good advice. If you really want to know more about headphones check out this forum

Most people on this board are quite inexperienced and suggest Sony, who can make decent high-end phones, but make a plethora of crappy headphones. Sony only gets recommend due to their saturation, not quality.
 

spinne1

macrumors 6502a
ieani said:
That is because sony makes some of the worst headphones you can buy.
While it is true for many Sony models, the larger over-ear type Sony MDR-7506s that I have and have used now for about 11 years are fantastic. For home listening, I recommend them highly, even if only with an iPod. I would not recommend any other Sony headphone as I've heard bad things about a few of them, but this particular model I CAN say is the best I have heard (and I've tried some "nicer" models from Sennheiser and Beyerdynamic and found them lacking in comparison.)

I don't like in ear phones and therefore can't say much about them.
 

calebjohnston

macrumors 68000
Jan 24, 2006
1,801
1
I have some closed-ear Sony headphones and the quality is actually very, very good. A little more bass would definetely be nice, but they sound incredible. I just have a problem with the noise cancelling pressure effect mentioned earlier. I get a headache after having them switched on for too long.
 

derajfast

macrumors 6502a
Mar 24, 2004
784
0
i think bose are sooo overrated and overpriced.....sennheiser makes the best cans


hd650

they are huge though, but kill anything bose has to offer
 

SharksFan22

macrumors regular
Dec 29, 2003
170
21
Bay Area, CA
When I used to work in music production and radio, Sennheiser was the norm. They make a fantastic product, but also aren't shy about charging for it. :)

I have a pair of Sennheisers that I use at home and Bose noise-cancelling ones for when I travel. The first time I used th Bose ones on a plane I was absolutely stunned at how well they worked. Not only was ambient noise minimized, but I didn't have to run the PowerBook and iPod volumes at 100% to hear things. I was also surprised to notice that after a coast-to-coast flight, I felt MUCH more refreshed and relaxed. I'm assuming it because I was playing things at normal audio levels and I also didn't have the constant drone of the jet engines pounding my senses for six hours.

All in all, if you travel, I recommend getting them. I'm happy with the Bose ones but can't speak for others.