Funny isn't it, the guys here complain about the narrow-mindedness of PC owners yet exhibit the same thing when it comes to PC's. It's not a laptop, it's a transportable. The keyboard comes off too. An all-in-one LANparty PC if you will, or for people like me who do like the idea of a transportable desktop (the reason why I bought the MBP17). For occasional transport it wouldn't make a huge difference over the 17" MBP in terms of 'portability' and it's a much better-specced machine.
Hmmm. I was thinking about buying a spare MBP 17" for when that machine develops yet another problem but I guess I can consider this too. Honestly if it weren't for OS X these days I've come to the conclusion I wouldn't touch Apple hardware with a barge pole - Nice-looking, nicely-designed, poorly engineered and unreliable. I'll bet that Dell would have a better shot at a trouble-free life.