Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I am not sure a failure is less likely to happen during the AC coverage period.

The 2016 and 2017 MBPs are all within the 3 year window for AC coverage. There are 3 class action suits in progress regarding the keyboard for the MacBook and 2016 and 2107 MacBook Pro models with the new keyboard. So there the need for the keyboard replacement does not yet appear to be a function of system age. And AC can cover you from an expensive keyboard repair in years 2 and 3 of ownership.

It may turn out the frequency of the problem increases as the systems age, like the 2011 MBP GPU failures. But, only time will tell.
I agree, but given Apples current solution to KB issues is compressed air cleaning the chances of "Dust" etc in your KB can only increase over time :D
 
I agree, but given Apples current solution to KB issues is compressed air cleaning the chances of "Dust" etc in your KB can only increase over time :D

Good point. Strange that company feels the need to have a page showing you how to hold it to clean it properly but refuses to acknowledge there is an issue. Legalities and liabilities no doubt play a role
 
[doublepost=1529040254][/doublepost]
I am pretty sure that in the US, "regular" AppleCare is no longer available and that buyers of new Macs or other Apple hardware/devices have only the option of purchasing AppleCare + .....and that, as already mentioned, it must be obtained within 60 days of the purchase of the Mac or iOS device.

https://www.apple.com/search/Applecare?page=1&sel=accessories&src=serp

You're right, Applecare Plus only in the US...but not the situation in the UK yet. Hopefully Plus coming to UK soon (just after I bought standard Applecare for two Macs at a higher price than US Applecare+ :().

The UK equivalent page to yours is:

https://www.apple.com/uk/search/applecare+?src=serp
 
Last edited:
[doublepost=1529040254][/doublepost]

You're right, Applecare Plus only in the US...but not the situation in the UK yet. Hopefully Plus coming to UK soon (just after I bought standard Applecare for two Macs at a higher price than US Applecare+ :().

The UK equivalent page to yours is:

https://www.apple.com/uk/search/applecare+?src=serp

Since we don't know where the OP is located, I felt it would be a good idea to post information that is relevant to Apple customers in the US. If he or she is in fact a US resident who had purchased the MBP ten months or so ago in this country, then as has been stated, unfortunately the time for getting AppleCare + coverage has long since passed.
 
My 2017 just had the B key fail, and I had applecare. I figured Im guaranteed to need a new battery by the time the 3 years are up, and a battery costs $129 to replace so 269-129= $130 marginal cost of not getting applecare. I'd say its worth it considering its a $2500 purchase for me and plus my Amex card gives me an extra year on top of that
 
So I totally almost bought apple care, mainly for the keyboard issue.. and then apple came up with the announcement of 4 years free repair on the keyboard issue.

now again I am not sure what to do.
 
Same boat here - my warranty is up next month - was 100% set on doing it, because of the keyboard issues.

Tbh, I don't think I'll bother now. The machine, other than the keyboard, seems rock solid. Haven't heard of any GPU failures, which is the other thing that's normally iffy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Abaganov
Same boat here - my warranty is up next month - was 100% set on doing it, because of the keyboard issues.
You might have a two year warranty if use you a credit card that offers that, such as Amex. It couldn't hurt to check and that gives you another year without paying a lot of $$ for AC
[doublepost=1530270508][/doublepost]
I figured Im guaranteed to need a new battery by the time the 3 years are up,
I know my usage is not the same as everyone, but my 2012 MBP's battery lasted until 2018 :eek:

You may not need a battery replacement in three years
 
You might have a two year warranty if use you a credit card that offers that, such as Amex. It couldn't hurt to check and that gives you another year without paying a lot of $$ for AC
[doublepost=1530270508][/doublepost]
I know my usage is not the same as everyone, but my 2012 MBP's battery lasted until 2018 :eek:

You may not need a battery replacement in three years

Amex over here only offers the extended warranty on the basic green card (which is odd). But we do have better consumer law which can help in some circumstances.

I wonder if Amex allow complementary cards - that would be useful - e.g. if I could get a green to go with my plat for purchases like this. Too late now though!
 
  • Like
Reactions: maflynn
I wonder if Amex allow complementary cards - that would be useful - e.g. if I could get a green to go with my plat for purchases like this. Too late now though!

That may vary by locale, but in the US it's quite possible to have multiple cards from the same issuer (Amex included).
 
Before the repair program was announced, I would have bought AppleCare.

But now, I would not.
- The keyboard is covered for 4 years (no AppleCare needed).
- The display may be covered by "StainGate" (not sure if Apple is covering newer releases with it or not).
- The battery (if it swells up) will probably get replaced free as a safety issue. Even if not, the replacement cost runs about $200, which you would have spent on AppleCare anyway.

So... I'd let AC be, and take my chances...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Abaganov
My 1 year warranty and 1 year time window to get AppleCare on my 2017 15" MPB will expire in 2 months.
so far I had no problems at all and very happy with the machine.

how insane is it not getting AppleCare for this machine considering the keyboard problem many people complain about? $349 is a pretty stiff price.

I would get it, my fully loaded 2016 MBP 15, just completely died. First MBP to die, just wouldn’t turn on. Sent in for repair yesterday. Serious bummer since I have been on a trip for the last few weeks. Second AC use on this MBP, replaced the keyboard a few months ago.
 
My 1 year warranty and 1 year time window to get AppleCare on my 2017 15" MPB will expire in 2 months.
so far I had no problems at all and very happy with the machine.

how insane is it not getting AppleCare for this machine considering the keyboard problem many people complain about? $349 is a pretty stiff price.
Where are you located that you can still by AppleCare (not AC+), and that it is $ denominated? Is that CDN or AUS or what?
 
Before the repair program was announced, I would have bought AppleCare.

But now, I would not.
- The keyboard is covered for 4 years (no AppleCare needed).
- The display may be covered by "StainGate" (not sure if Apple is covering newer releases with it or not).
- The battery (if it swells up) will probably get replaced free as a safety issue. Even if not, the replacement cost runs about $200, which you would have spent on AppleCare anyway.

So... I'd let AC be, and take my chances...

And when the logic board fails like mine just did?
 
And when the logic board fails like mine just did?
This in a larger context means zip :)

Your either an inny or an outty :D

Once your down the road of opting in for extended warranties or risk based insurance it's hard to stop but if you have always opted out on all major appliances and look across the longer terms despite having more stuff should increase the odds of failures you can't ignore that by and large the majority have a balanced success rate of no repairs

Even just on the 20 or 30 plus Apple devices I have had only one has had a minor repair let alone throwing in TV's washing machines etc in to the equation

Call me lucky ( I hope not on so called premium laptops etc) but I am $1000's better of than for not opting for AC and can easily take the odd $1k hit

Sure there is the odd user that's been stuffed several times in a row but they are few and far between and really their lesson learned is not to buy products from the same vendor let alone say Apple are good because of AC

I can see the risk has increased since the new build method as repair rates have rocketed and if you keep your device longer than 3 years it makes even less sense to opt for AC

Do what makes you feel happy but probably buying a new device more frequently or opting out gives you far better experience overall
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.