Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

applemax

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Feb 22, 2005
1,032
3
Hi

Just did a speed test on my iPhone.

The first result is with tethering off, the second with it on.

It seems to me that some sort of throttling is going on seeing as both tests are done in the same place at the same time on the same phone. Any ideas?

Thanks :D
 

Attachments

  • photo.jpg
    photo.jpg
    40.2 KB · Views: 145
  • photo 2.jpg
    photo 2.jpg
    41.4 KB · Views: 138
Well, when you're tethered, wouldn't you want the speed test to be run on your PC?

Isn't this a bit like if i run a speedtest on my PC when I've got Bit Torrent running, the results are slow because BT is taking up much of the bandwidth that the speedtest would use. Wouldn't tethering be eating up the available bandwidth as well?
 
Well, when you're tethered, wouldn't you want the speed test to be run on your PC?

Isn't this a bit like if i run a speedtest on my PC when I've got Bit Torrent running, the results are slow because BT is taking up much of the bandwidth that the speedtest would use. Wouldn't tethering be eating up the available bandwidth as well?

It's irrelevant which device does the speed test - the connection is going through the phone. What these two images show is that when tethering is activated, there is clearly a drop in performance, and to me, it looks like a deliberately throttled connection, whether it's being used on a computer or an iPhone.

While tethering is activated, you can still use the internet on your phone. This test was done with tethering activated, and the computer inactive.

I've emailed O2, but I'm extremely confused as to why I'm losing 2.5Mbit/s and paying £15 a month for the privilege! :confused:
 
Is your test a fair test?

Did you do three tests and work out an average? If not, do this again, properly, and report back.
 
Is your test a fair test?

Did you do three tests and work out an average? If not, do this again, properly, and report back.

:p

I don't need to do three tests. The difference between the two results is so vast, that no mean average is going to help it. Can anyone seriously help? :confused: :)
 
My question would be while tethered what was the PC doing? Ie was it polling for mail or anything else in the background. Just because you don't think you have anything running doesn't mean something somewhere isn't doing something via the network connection.
 
Both tests were done on the phone so it is 100% a network issue.
 
Both tests were done on the phone so it is 100% a network issue.

yes we get that...what we also want to know is what else was the PC doing? for all we know you were downloading via bit torrent or watching BBC iplayer.
 
It's irrelevant which device does the speed test - the connection is going through the phone. What these two images show is that when tethering is activated, there is clearly a drop in performance, and to me, it looks like a deliberately throttled connection, whether it's being used on a computer or an iPhone.

While tethering is activated, you can still use the internet on your phone. This test was done with tethering activated, and the computer inactive.

I've emailed O2, but I'm extremely confused as to why I'm losing 2.5Mbit/s and paying £15 a month for the privilege! :confused:

No it's not.
The application monitoring the network speed will be sending and recieving data, and determining how fast this is happening.

if you are tethering, any data being sent and recieved on the computer youare tethering too, will not be counted in the application you are using

Or this is at least how I believe whatever your using will work..
 
As I have said, the computer was inactive during the test.

When tethering is turned on, the speed grinds to a halt, regardless of the state of the computer.

- it looks like a network issue. How can I fix it?
 
I just did a speed test on the computer and it read 101kbps. Something is not right here, and there is extremely little network activity to steal bandwidth from the speed test.

I'm certain that something is regulating the speed as this sudden drop in speed only occurs when I turn on tethering.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.