I've been using the black case since Friday. As soon as you put it on the phone you notice the high quality feel and super tight fit.
Removing the case is a different story. It is extremely hard to remove. I have taken it off about 3 times now.
Unfortunately, the lock button on the top of my phone is loose and jiggles now.
For those who want to remove the case I suggest you remove by pushing the bottom of the phone out first because you will damage or "loosen" your buttons if you remove from the top.
Already, have an appointment for the apple store this week so they can hopefully repair it. Don't have much hope for a replacement since inventory is soooo low for the gold on AT&T.