Mame OS X is extremely outdated.
Outdated how? If it plays the games I want to play, then it's still relevant to me, at least. More importantly, I don't feel like playing "chase the romset" anymore. The MAME teams regularly FRACK with the roms and rom names and make Mame refuse to run the game even when the rom isn't actually USED in the emulation. So unless they have a rom checker that will automatically find the roms for you, I'll skip it. I've got thousands of ROMs and I don't want to update tons of them. In fact, just to get Mame OS X running, I made a list of games I'd actually play and only updates the roms that needed it from that list (couple hundred at most). I used to chase that "got to have them all" collector routine back in the early 2000s and realized it was STUPID when I'll never play 99.9% of them.
Really, it would be nice if someone would take over the Mame OS X project. It had a pretty decent front-end. Yes, it could be improved (Mame32 was where it was at on Windows), but when you've got a Mac you can't always be picky. I still have a Windows machine and can run Window virtually, but I hate doing if I don't have to.
Also, SDLMame has a GUI. It is simple, but it does what it needs to do, list games and run them.
To me, that's a poor excuse in 2015. Mame32 was AWESOME back in 2000 even! The fact that a decade and a half later there's some half-baked version of Mame still floating around due to nothing but laziness (i.e. no will to make a good frontend built-in) on the part of the Mame developers...well screw them. Yeah, I can say that now because I don't care anymore. Everyone was always so careful to kiss their butts lest they get upset and not finish their Mortal Kombat 4 emulation or whatever crap. These guys never had any interest in playing the games, just playing collector. That's why they got perverse pleasure out of changing the rom set names every single version, just to screw with people!
Also command line is still useful for discerning between rom variations and sets.
Yeah and Linux is a real desktop operating system. That's why I'm using OS X....
Also, I took a look at the source. OpenEmu is still using Mame .149 as its core, so a lot of the romsets are outdated. For Arcade, i am going to stick with SDLMame.
Yeah and what new games or improvements have their been that those romsets are "outdated"? Don't you think after 15-20 years, the rom sets should be pretty damn stable by now? I'd sure as hell think so. No, I always believed that they changed them just to screw with people 85% of the time (I mean just changing the NAMES of the roms that don't even have names for real!) That's what freeloaders/leeches get in their minds.
The only interest I have in a newer Mame version is that Mess is now a part of it. I haven't looked at MESS in some time, but it wasn't making a lot of useful progress compared to separate emulators for all those years I followed that stuff. I mean why use a half-baked Mess version of a C64 emulation if VICE works almost 100%? Mess never really had any good front-ends made for it either. I had a Mame32 based one that worked well for some things (cartridges), but it was kind of messy for discs, etc. but still better than nothing (i.e. command line). I have no idea if it's improved any overall or what systems work on it, etc. but I have separate emulations for the ones I care about (i.e. Amiga, C64, Atari 800) and OpenEmu seems pretty good for a Mac now for the game consoles, overall (Atari/Intellivsion/Coleco/NES stuff all works great and most of the newer stuff as well as far as I can tell). Most of it is just nostalgia for me anyway. I'm not really oging to play games I never got around to playing or something. I just like to crank out a game of AD&D, Adventure or WarRoom once in awhile.