Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Which?

  • Buy the 5S, don't buy the mini

    Votes: 4 21.1%
  • Buy the mini, keep the 4S.

    Votes: 15 78.9%

  • Total voters
    19

FX4568

macrumors 6502
Original poster
So I have a 4S, and with the release of the 5S, my contract is up.
I was thinking of switching to pre-paid with the 4S and save a good $300 a year, and get an iPad mini.
My logic is the following, my iPhone is mainly used as texting, calling and listening to music on the go. I rarely use it to browse the web or even play games. I take pictures, but I think the 4S is good enough.

I would get the iPad mini to use it at home when im browsing the web or taking a ****, taking few notes, and watching movies.

Obviously, I can already do the above with my MBA, but obviously, I want something new.

So what do you guys think? Use the money I will save by going pre-paid and buy a mini, or just switch to the 5S and keep using my MBA.
 
I'm in a similar situation; iphone 4s, macbook pro retina 15", ipad mini. I am torn between upgrading the phone, ipad, or potentially both.

However, since upgrading my phone to ios 7, I think I will keep this until the 6 comes out and hopefully is a more substantial upgrade. As much as I love my ipad mini (which I sold my ipad 3 for), I think the ipad 5 will be exactly what I want.

So in summary, i'll be selling the ipad mini to upgrade for the ipad 5 and keeping the 4s for another year.
 
If you haven't had any experience with an iPad before, you should get one instead of upgrading an iPhone. I think you already have an answer 😉

iPad is actually a magical device because you can focus on what you do and nothing else. This is when technology goes away 🙂
 
My uses for my iPhone are similar to yours.

I have an iPhone 5 and was looking to upgrade to the 5S or 5C but after really thinking about it; I figured by updating to iOS7, this will give my iPhone 5 a new breath of life therefore I'll just save my money towards replacing my iPad 3 (where i get the most enjoyment) to the rumored iPad 5😀 and wait to get the iPhone 6 next year, when I believe Apple will most probably redesign the model.
 
So I have a 4S, and with the release of the 5S, my contract is up.
I was thinking of switching to pre-paid with the 4S and save a good $300 a year, and get an iPad mini.
My logic is the following, my iPhone is mainly used as texting, calling and listening to music on the go. I rarely use it to browse the web or even play games. I take pictures, but I think the 4S is good enough.

I would get the iPad mini to use it at home when im browsing the web or taking a ****, taking few notes, and watching movies.

Obviously, I can already do the above with my MBA, but obviously, I want something new.

So what do you guys think? Use the money I will save by going pre-paid and buy a mini, or just switch to the 5S and keep using my MBA.

Since you dont game/web browse on a mobile device, i think its unnecessary to buy the mini. Furthermore, web browsing/taking notes will be much better on MBA.
 
What would you do then if you were in my position?

get a mini, I have one and a MBP, sure I don't use the iPad as much since I got it but it still has it's useless. But since all you do is text/call/music it would be useless to go pay more money for a phone that has almost no use to you
 
I would keep the 4S and get the mini. From your usage the 4S seems like it will be fine for you for a while longer. Also, the way I look at it unless the device you want to upgrade is broken/ doesn't suit your needs anymore, it makes more sense to get a device you don't already have as it adds to what you have.

I had a different dilemma this weekend. I have a Samsug galaxy S4 an iPad mini and a Samsung galaxy tab 2 10.1. I had an iPod touch 5th gen but gifted it to my younger cousin as a reward for doing well in his exams last month. Was trying to decide between upgrading my galaxy tab to a galaxy note 10.1 or picking up a new iPod touch. In the end I went for the iPod touch, as I reasoned that my tab 2 works well enough and isn't my only tablet. Yet at the moment I don't have an iPod touch and miss the functionality of it.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.