After my iPhone 5 bent in an otterbox defender (and I have no idea how) I will never use them anymore. I was a real believer in them until then. They don't last much more than 6 months before they start falling apart either. The rubber gets loose and sometimes rips. They used to replace them with no questions asked but it became harder to get replacements. I still have defenders on my iPads and they've been great, just a little rubber sagging issues after 2 years of moderate use. The iPad case is nice that it has a shell that snaps over the front when you're not using it. It also doubles as a stand if using on a table.