I have to admit, the otter box's cases for iphone 5 havnt been as good as in the past. I have the commuter in blue on my phone now and the silicone is faded and stretched a bit but today I dropped my phone from about 5 feet (maybe more) onto the cement floor in wal mart. It landed flat on the back of the phone and made a horrible SMACK sound that even made the cashier say "ooohhh is it ok?" There isn't a scratch or a crack on the case!