Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

AnthroMatt

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Jun 8, 2011
798
811
Good morning. I have had the Commuter case on my iPhone 4 for about a week now. I want to ask if I just got an ill-fitting or ill-made case or if all the Otterbox Commuter cases have this problem and therefore exchanging the product would do me no good...thanks in advance.

The first picture was taken with the case on...note the upper corners of the image. The second was taken caseless.

photo1.jpg


photo2.jpg
 
Good morning. I have had the Commuter case on my iPhone 4 for about a week now. I want to ask if I just got an ill-fitting or ill-made case or if all the Otterbox Commuter cases have this problem and therefore exchanging the product would do me no good...thanks in advance.

The first picture was taken with the case on...note the upper corners of the image. The second was taken caseless.

Image

Image

I have heard of some defect issues with fit on the Commuter cases, I would first check if when you place the hardshell piece on the iPhone if the silicon underneath slides. If after perfect visual alignment you still get that vignette effect, I would contact Otterbox for a replacement, they are usually pretty good about that. Hope this helps!
 
I have heard of some defect issues with fit on the Commuter cases, I would first check if when you place the hardshell piece on the iPhone if the silicon underneath slides. If after perfect visual alignment you still get that vignette effect, I would contact Otterbox for a replacement, they are usually pretty good about that. Hope this helps!

Thanks. I was able to exchange the case at Best Buy, the new one offered no improvement. I contacted Otterbox on Monday and will await their response.
 
Just to follow up, Otterbox is going to send a replacement case (different model).

Excellent customer service!
 
Just to follow up, Otterbox is going to send a replacement case (different model).

Excellent customer service!

Yea it's great until you wait for the replacement...

Mine took almost 2.5 weeks! However, it was brand new in a retail box. I was just expecting the case itself.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.