Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

LaCosta

macrumors member
Original poster
Mar 31, 2011
50
8
I read here that many rave about the Otterbox Commuter. A hybrid case that has silicone.

When I look at the silicone, it is a bit softer than many others that I have seen.

What is the life of the silicone? Does it get stretched out? Does it tear? How about the polycarbonate...does it scratch or discolor (thinking of getting the white shell).

Thanks for your thoughts.
 
I read here that many rave about the Otterbox Commuter. A hybrid case that has silicone.

When I look at the silicone, it is a bit softer than many others that I have seen.

What is the life of the silicone? Does it get stretched out? Does it tear? How about the polycarbonate...does it scratch or discolor (thinking of getting the white shell).

Thanks for your thoughts.

Otterbox has a guarantee. If you need a new silicon they'll send you a knew one no questions asked.
 
Otterbox has a guarantee. If you need a new silicon they'll send you a knew one no questions asked.

Isn't the Otterbox guarantee only for one year? Perhaps one year warranty is good enough.

So....does the silicone case stretch out where it requires a replacement?
 
Isn't the Otterbox guarantee only for one year? Perhaps one year warranty is good enough.

So....does the silicone case stretch out where it requires a replacement?

Yes but it also depends on how vigorously you use it.
 
Thanks everyone to help me with my case selection.

I purchased an Otterbox Commuter and it has been great. First few days the edging of my wet applied screen protector started slightly to come up....but I would just get the bubble out and it would adhere without any marks or distortion. Then after the Otterbox silicone broke in, it no longer was causing an issue.

I like how the poly carbonate shell is holding and firming up the silicone. And the little bit of silicone that is showing gives the impression that it will protect the phone in a drop.

I like the Commuter. Thanks.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.