Whilst I'm sure this has been debated somewhere on this vast forum, I can't find a straight-up comparison. I've looked at all the iPhone 4 reviews for both cases, and I just can't decide which one to pick up for my brand new shiny iPhone 4S. I'm pretty sure it'll be one of the two. Anyone with any experience with either care to share their opinions please? Also, does the antenna get scratched using either cases (probably not, but I need a perfect resale in 12 months time, so...) If anyone's completely against these cases, could you recommend something with similar protection but more to your liking?