Just un-boxed it and took off my Griffin Survivor All-Terrain. I must say I am impressed. The phone fits good and snug in the case and it does not rattle. The on/off and volume buttons are easier to use than the Griffin. The entire back rubber case is not as thick as the Griffin and it does not have the raised areas. The rubber seems smoother, yet I still have a good grip on the phone. Will get some pictures later on once my day slows down a bit. All in all, I give it high marks, and will buy three more for my other family members. The Griffins are now for sale, once Otter starts selling more of them!