So, I'm less than pleased, no no, I'm furious. I got an OtterBox Defender about a week after getting the 4S, fast forward 4 months, the silicone rubber is stretching, no biggie, we all get lemons sometimes, so I ask for a new outer and Otterbox grants it, I just got it today, I go to put it on AND IT DOESN'T FIT. I've tried to like them for their durability and I just can't, has this happened to someone else? I'm in the "I'm not giving this company another dime" frame of mind currently. Sorry, mini-rant over.