You can get a full fledged PC laptop for $400. Getting this instead would be dumb, especially for cash strapped college students. They get a whole lot more for their $400 than they do for the $600 (less $100 rebate) this thing costs.
$359 on sale weekends for Vista-running PC laptops. I already have one of these Palm inventions: it weight a little more, costs quite a bite more, but it does a *whole lot* more: a MacBook.
Don't get me wrong. I switched from a paper calendar to a Palm LifeDrive, and really like it -- I'd love it if it was even 2/3 as easy to take notes on it as paper -- because I do like iCal, I do keep my calendar there, and I was tired of each month sitting down and copying out my iCal entries to my paper diary. And then remembering to copy out any changes. So it just made sense. The LifeDrive works with my MacBook to save me time and add convenience. It's a MacBook "companion", that does more in the diary functions than my iPod. But now the Treo, which is primarily a phone needs a companion which is then a companion to a full notebook computer. Come on.
This, and Microsoft releases a $5,000 - $10,000 touch-screen table display for computers and we're all supposed to go mad over the innovation of it. It's like the props budget for a top-tier science fiction movie. Throw in every gee-whiz technology they can simulate on screen -- to give you that future feel. Both Palm's Foleo and Microsoft's well, whatever it is, are just gadget proliferation. Which is antithetical to using technology to simplify what you do. I still keep notes on post-its stuck to the wall in front of my desk, and in paper notebooks. I know *a lot* of people who work like this, only transcribing to computer that which ultimately becomes essential, or part of the final project.
There's just no "technology to improve your work process" anymore from most designers. I'll spare the Apple TV that criticism. It sits on the table behind our HDTV in our living room, attached to our A/V system. I never see it, I never do anything with it -- except infrequently when I want to copy a new movie to it, because I've set that for manual configuration. I see the remote. My Apple TV, as far as I know, as I far as what I deal with, is the size of a very thin pack of chewing gum. And it plays music, movies and TV shows. A laptop for a phone so you can leave your laptop on your desk, and a big touch-screen video display novelty table item? These are improvements how?