Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Which set of devices would you choose?

  • Windows PC, iPad, Android phone

    Votes: 3 16.7%
  • Windows PC, Android tablet, iPhone

    Votes: 2 11.1%
  • Mac, Windows tablet, Android phone

    Votes: 6 33.3%
  • Mac, Android tablet, Windows phone

    Votes: 4 22.2%
  • Linux (incl Chrome OS) PC, Windows tablet, iPhone

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Linux (incl Chrome OS) PC, iPad, Windows phone

    Votes: 3 16.7%

  • Total voters
    18
  • Poll closed .

ozaz

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Feb 27, 2011
1,626
598
Purely hypothetical question asked for fun.

Imagine you only have one PC, one tablet, and one smartphone. You can only have one OS from each source (company). How you you distribute your devices?

Notes:

By PC, I mean a traditional form factor computer (desktop/laptop). Hybrid laptops allowed as long as the screen is *not detachabale* (e.g. Lenovo Yoga)

By tablet, I mean slate form factor devices (like iPad). Hybrid tablets allowed as long as screen *is detachable* (e.g. Asus transformer)

To minimise permutations, I have bundled Linux and Chromebooks together.
 
This was actually a fun poll to take a moment to consider.

Windows computer options:

Will be most likely buying/building one soon for gaming, but last I remember iTunes for Windows was atrocious and I've had Android devices for 3 years now, so I would appreciate a bit of change.

I ended up choosing Mac, Android tablet, and Windows phone.

OS X is just fine, while Windows phone seems like a really intriguing option in terms of a mobile OS that I would love to test out. Also, I don't know of many true tablets with Win 8 (I see the Surface Pro as a laptop replacement, though RT is a possibility), but I do know Android and would be fine with that on a larger screen. It came down to wanting something new I would use more often, so I picked Windows Phone over a Windows tablet.
 
Mac, Windows Tablet and Android phone.

Then sell the tablet and phone to fund an iPhone!

Just give me a Mac and iPhone and I will be happy for life (upgrading to the newer models every few year!)
 
If I can only pick one of each, it's gotta be a PC for gaming, a Surface for on the move, and a Windows Phone, because I wouldn't use any other phone.
 
Mac, skip the smartphone and get a feature phone, and then no tablet.

There is no point in getting three devices with different operating systems on them. It's just money being wasted. I'd rather buy my apps for the iPhone and iPad twice, than apps for the iPad then the same app for Android/Windows Phone.
 
There is no point in getting three devices with different operating systems on them. It's just money being wasted.

It's not something being given serious consideration. It's just a playful thought thought experiment designed to see which class of apple product people on here value most (mac, iphone, or ipad).

----------

Hmm, that's a tough one >_< I'd probably go for a Mac, a Windows tablet and an iPhone.

Not allowed. That's two apple products. I probably should not have put OS in the title as you have interpreted OS X and iOS as different. Of course, they are. But for the purpose of this exercise, they are considered the same (both from Apple).
 
PC -> Windows for gaming
Tablet -> Windows tablet
Phone -> iPhone

It's really hard to choose iOS on the tablet or on the phone but I choose it on the phone!
 
It's not something being given serious consideration. It's just a playful thought thought experiment designed to see which class of apple product people on here value most (mac, iphone, or ipad).

Of course. I value my Mac above all in the end. And if I couldn't have an iPad, I wouldn't get a tablet. I did get an Android tablet to begin with, but I probably let the battery drain for a month without using it and then used it for my textbooks.

And unless it's a phone that I can do more than just talk and text (because I only have a phone to call my parents), then I wouldn't have one. I don't want to carry a brick, because that's mostly what a cellphone is to me, a brick that rings once every two weeks.
 
PC -> Windows for gaming
Tablet -> Windows tablet
Phone -> iPhone

It's really hard to choose iOS on the tablet or on the phone but I choose it on the phone!

Not allowed Windows PC and Windows tablet.
I must have worded the original post really badly :eek:
 
Not allowed Windows PC and Windows tablet.
I must have worded the original post really badly :eek:

I was thinking windows RT it's different than normal windows... But maybe a android tablet then with sd card so I could fill it with movies and tv shows
 
I'd go with Mac, Android Tablet, and finally Windows Phone.

Mac for the great operating system, Android on a tablet for probably the best mix of "walled garden" and PC type situations, and then Windows Phone for a reliable smartphone OS.
 
No way I'm going without a Mac :eek:

I use a tablet mostly to read and watch video. Even a crappy Surface would probably suffice even though it wouldn't be a great experience.

Android for the phone mostly because of the app choice due to its massive install base.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.